Posted by: zanshin, 2008-11-28 06:22

Story

Media Forced To Backtrack On Al-Qaeda Link To Mumbai Attacks
Paul Joseph Watson, 2008-11-28 (Friday), Prison Planet
But attacks which have a purely domestic agenda are blown out of all proportion by corporate media as poster child for ailing war on terror


After brazenly declaring that the Mumbai attacks were the work of Al-Qaeda, the corporate media has been forced to backtrack, while India continues to blame Pakistan in a dangerous escalation of rhetoric between the two nuclear-armed powers.

Bellicose propaganda about Bin Laden being behind the massacre, which was initially propagated by the BBC, London Times and Fox News amongst others, has largely evaporated, with the majority of the establishment press being forced to admit they have no idea who was behind the siege on India’s financial capital.

However, India’s claim that Pakistan had a hand in the attacks is beginning to find favor in the U.S., where one counterterrorism official told CNN, “the level of sophistication in the attack leads officials to believe that it might be tied to Lashkar-e-Tayyiba (Army of the Pure), an Islamic extremist group that has carried out previous attacks in India.”

Lashkar-e-Tayyiba would be a useful scapegoat because it has alleged links both to Al-Qaeda and Pakistani’s ISI secret service, but since the group has vehemently denied responsibility and terrorists normally like to claim responsibility for their handiwork, any attempt to pin the blame is likely to run out of steam. Lashkar-e-Tayyiba always claim responsibility for their attacks, so their outright denial is the death knell for this explanation.

That India would immediately exploit the tragedy to demonize their arch-enemy Pakistan was fully expected, but how Pakistan, which has recently made numerous peaceful overtures towards India, could possibly benefit from crazed terrorists indiscriminately gunning down innocent people in shocking scenes played out on international television defies belief.

But that reasoning did not prevent India’s Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee from telling a press conference today that, “Preliminary evidence, prima facie evidence, indicates elements with links to Pakistan are involved.”

In reality, as we have repeatedly emphasized, the attacks were likely not the work of Al-Qaeda, Pakistan, the Mossad or the CIA, but Indian Muslims.

As author Tariq Ali points out today, “The Indian Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, has insisted that the terrorists were based outside the country. The Indian media has echoed this line of argument with Pakistan (via the Lashkar-e-Taiba) and al-Qaeda listed as the usual suspects.”

“But this is a meditated edifice of official India’s political imagination. Its function is to deny that the terrorists could be a homegrown variety, a product of the radicalization of young Indian Muslims who have finally given up on the indigenous political system. To accept this view would imply that the country’s political physicians need to heal themselves.”

“Why should it be such a surprise if the perpetrators are themselves Indian Muslims? Its hardly a secret that there has been much anger within the poorest sections of the Muslim community against the systematic discrimination and acts of violence carried out against them of which the 2002 anti-Muslim pogrom in shining Gujarat was only the most blatant and the most investigated episode, supported by the Chief Minister of the State and the local state apparatuses.”

“Add to this the continuing sore of Kashmir which has for decades been treated as a colony by Indian troops with random arrests, torture and rape of Kashmiris an everyday occurrence. Conditions have been much worse than in Tibet, but have aroused little sympathy in the West where the defense of human rights is heavily instrumentalised.”

The identity and motive behind the terrorists is reasonably clear, these young men are disenfranchised, revenge-driven Indian Muslims, along with a smattering of Pakistanis, Kashmiris and Bangladeshis, based in India not Pakistan, who hate Hindus and believe it is their duty to kick-start a wider tribal war, which is why the vast majority of those killed were Indians, not foreigners, Brits or Americans.

The terrorists were not dispatched on their mission by the Pakistan government or Osama bin Laden, they are mostly Indians who represent a domestic problem for the Indian government, which is why the authorities are seeking to deflect blame and exploit the tragedy to demonize Pakistan in the eyes of the international community.

The spin that the terrorists deliberately targeted American and British citizens is still being pumped out by the western corporate media, despite the fact that only one Briton died, himself being originally from Cyprus, in comparison to well over a hundred Indians, and despite the fact that the rampage was a completely indiscriminate massacre.

The western propaganda machine has taken a domestic problem, which expresses itself almost on a monthly basis in India with routine bombings and attacks, and amplified it beyond all proportion to claim that the attacks were an assault on western democracy, capitalism, and ultimately the Anglo-American power alliance.

The horrible slaughter of hundreds of mostly Indian civilians in Mumbai will now be used as a poster child for continued bombing campaigns inside Pakistani territory and an expansion of the ailing war on terror under President elect Barack Obama, which in the long term only means that more innocent lives will be lost.

Comments


No comments yet.

Please login to post your comment.












All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Stories, Arguments and Comments are owned by the Poster.
The Rest copyright © 2007 Argumentations.com. All rights reserved. Argumentations.com provides material for research or educational purposes only. We do not warrant the correctness of its contents. The risk from using it lies entirely with the user. While using this site, you agree to have read and accepted our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Argumentations.com is far from perfect so if you have any critiques, questions, comments or problems about this site please tell us. Click here to send your feedback. And if you like Argumentations.com please link to this site. It will really help a lot.
   

Tags

Al-Qaeda,   Capitalism,   CIA,   Counterterrorism,   Cyprus,   democracy,   Human Rights,   India,   ISI,   Kashmir,   Lashkar-e-Toiba,   Manmohan Singh,   MUSLIM,   Muslims,   Obama,   Osama bin Laden,   Pakistan,   Tariq Ali,   Tibet,   Torture,  

Related statements

View other suggested stories

Date added 
2008-11-28The Assault on Mumbai -- India's Leaders Need to Look Closer to Home
2006-10-09The Anglo-American War of Terror: An Overview
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 6 -- Terrorist Organizations
2007-11-16The Crisis Of Pakistan: A Dangerously Weak State
2008-09-13TERRORISM, HUMAN RIGHTS, SOCIAL JUSTICE, FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY: SOME CONSIDERATIONS FOR THE LEGAL AND JUSTICE PROFESSIONALS OF THE ‘COALITION OF THE WILLING’
2008-05-27Laptop Jihadi
2007-11-27A Muslim belongs in the Cabinet
2007-12-27A Conversation With Benazir Bhutto
2008-01-04Bhutto’s Deadly Legacy
2008-01-11The General in his Labyrinth
2008-02-29The new wars of religion
2007-06-22Al Qaeda Strikes Back
2007-08-20A False Choice in Pakistan
2006-10-13Interview Vali Nasr
2006-12-18“Osama’s Dream”
2007-03-03Scapegoating Pakistan
2008-08-21The Breaking Point -- A New Age of Torture
2008-09-26Copenhagen Consensus 2008 Challenge Paper Terrorism
2008-10-24The World Around Russia: 2017 -- An Outlook for the Midterm Future
2008-12-03Right at the Edge
2008-12-13Getting Away with Torture?
2009-02-11Renewing American Leadership
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 --
2007-04-17Terror group's threat raises Dalai Lama alert
2006-10-26Musharraf's confessions
2006-05-01Nuclear, terrorism issues to dominate Bush's first South Asia trip
2006-04-20The Next Iraqi War? Sectarianism and Civil Conflict
2007-09-08Knowing the Enemy
2007-09-09It's the Demography, Stupid
2007-09-17Why We're Losing the War on Terror
2007-08-12How the ‘Good War’ in Afghanistan Went Bad
2008-02-29Islamist Bubbles -- Beware the light at the end of the Islamist tunnel
2008-04-06Benazir Bhutto's 'Reconciliation': Islam, Democracy, and the West
2008-04-29The Pentagon's New Map
2008-01-10Daughter of the West
2007-12-28Al Qaeda In GHQ, Rawalpindi
2008-01-15Militants Escape Control of Pakistan, Officials Say
2007-11-11In the Wake of War: Geo-strategy, Terrorism, Oil Markets, and Domestic Politics
2007-09-28The Mega-Lie Called the "War on Terror": A Masterpiece of Propaganda
2007-10-12The Iconoclast
2009-05-12Rebranding the Long War, Part 1 -- Obama does his Bush impression
2009-04-04Can Pakistan Be Governed?
2009-02-22In the face of chaos
2009-01-16The Joint Operating Environment (JOE)
2009-07-20Transcript of President Barack Obama's speech at the National Archives
2008-12-10Profile: Lashkar-e-Taiba (Army of the Pure) (a.k.a. Lashkar e-Tayyiba, Lashkar e-Toiba; Lashkar-i-Taiba)
2008-11-27India's Singh blames neighbors as battle rages
2008-10-11Jihad: The Trail of Political Islam
2008-09-12A Grim Anniversary
2008-08-11Rethinking the National Interest -- American Realism for a New World
2008-08-12The Myth of Grass-Roots Terrorism -- Why Osama bin Laden Still Matters
2008-08-25The Worldwide Threat 2004: Challenges in a Changing Global Context
2008-09-02Can The War On Terror Be Won? -- How To Fight The Right War
2008-06-05Obliteration of Hinduism in Assam -- A perspective from Sri Aurobindo
2008-06-10Impeach George W. Bush Resolution
2007-10-20The War on Afghanistan Was Wrong, Too
2007-10-22The Secret History of the Impending War with Iran That the White House Doesn't Want You to Know
2007-10-23Torture in the Name of Freedom
2007-09-25Distorting Desire
2007-10-03Why the United States Invaded Iraq and is Now Thinking About Invading Iran
2007-11-04Pakistan Emergency
2007-11-04While Pakistan Burns
2007-11-21Afghanistan: 'Pashtunistan' Issues Linger Behind Afghan-Pakistani Row
2007-11-22Fool Me Once . . .
2007-11-26Norwegian Jihad -- Transcript
2007-12-02The Smart Way to Beat Tyrants Like Chavez
2007-12-12Al Qaeda's Best Publicist
2008-01-29THE WAR ON TERROR: FOUR YEARS ON; Taking Stock Of the Forever War
2007-12-18Turkey's EU Membership's Possible Impacts on the Middle East
2008-01-11After Iraq
2008-01-07For sale: West’s deadly nuclear secrets
2008-01-07Azzam the American -- The making of an Al Qaeda homegrown
2008-01-03Democracy is more than just fair elections - Benazir Bhutto
2008-04-25Planning For Planetary Interrogation — Cradle To Grave For Perfect Slave
2008-04-18Choosing War: The Decision to Invade Iraq and Its Aftermath
2008-04-04Interview: Lee Kuan Yew -- Part 1
2008-04-12Asia’s Republican Leanings
2008-04-13Holistic Integrative Analysis of International Change: A Commentary on Teaching Emergent Futures
2008-03-22"Allah Will Not Change the Condition of a People"
2008-03-23Dissecting the Danish Cartoon Controversy
2008-03-24It Wasn't On Oprah or Fox News -- How Could Hillary Have Known?
2008-03-03President Addresses Joint Armed Forces Officers' Wives' Luncheon
2008-02-26Fitzgerald: Islam for Infidels, Part Two
2008-03-14Aims and Methods of Europe's Muslim Brotherhood
2008-03-16Bush is an idiot, but he was right about Saddam
2007-08-08Red Mosque: Endgame for Musharraf?
2007-08-08Monsieur Lévy’s Working Holiday
2007-08-10Who Is Osama Bin Laden?
2007-08-06The Global Drug Meta-Group: Drugs, Managed Violence, and the Russian 9/11
2007-07-10Tariq Ramadan Has an Identity Issue
2007-07-12House Armed Services Committee Global Security Assessment Statement For The Record
2007-09-08Bin Laden Expert: He's Winning
2007-06-16African Gothic
2007-06-17General Tommy Franks -- An exclusive interview with America's top general in the war on terrorism
2007-06-08Political Islam
2007-06-22Symposium: Strategies of Death
2007-07-04Renewing American Leadership
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: South and Central Asia Overview
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 5 -- Terrorist Safe Havens (7120 Report)
2007-04-28C.I.A. Held Qaeda Leader in Secret Prison for Months
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Africa Overview
2006-05-01Can Democracy Stop Terrorism?
2006-10-13Regional Implications of Shi‘a
2006-11-26Islam, Terror and the Second Nuclear Age
2007-04-17Commission Adopts Resolutions On Combating Defamation Of Religions; Right To Development
2007-03-31India-Pakistan: Troubled Relations
2007-03-16Forrest Gump of Manufactured Terrorism Confesses from Gitmo Dungeon
2007-01-25Make War Your Friend, Part I
2006-12-06Transcript - The Nomination Hearing for Robert M. Gates
2007-01-14Natural Resources are Fuelling a New Cold War
2008-06-12Osama bin Laden and the U.S. economy: Bernd Debusmann
2008-06-17MUSLIMS of NEPAL: Becoming an assertive minority
2008-07-03'Countdown with Keith Olbermann' for Thursday, May 29
2008-08-09Chasing a Mirage
2008-08-07Brzezinski’s bunker
2008-07-20The Green Light
2008-07-25How to Get Away With Torture
2008-09-16Official American Sadism
2008-09-18US Genocide in Iraq
2008-09-26Has the U.S. Invasion of Pakistan Begun?
2008-09-23India's shame
2008-10-02U.S. Not Winning War on Terror -- Special Report
2008-10-13Restoring The Rule Of Law -- Testimony
2008-10-07A wild frontier -- Pakistan’s tribal areas
2008-10-30Pakistan: Waiting with bated breath
2008-10-31Preventing and Responding to Internal Conflict: When is it Right for Others to Intervene?
2008-11-23The American Mission?
2008-12-06Obama's War Cabinet
2008-12-07Obama’s Speech in Berlin -- Transcript
2008-12-03Symposium: Iran: The Countdown
2008-12-06Muslim Revolution -- How Washington Arrogance Helped Drive the Mumbai Attacks
2008-11-30EU2020 essay Willing and able? -- EU defence in 2020
2008-11-30Attacks Imperil Delicate U.S. Role Between Rivals
2008-11-07Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2008-11-08For Eyes of President-Elect Obama Only
2008-11-09Blueprint for Change -- Obama and Biden’s Plan for America
2008-11-10The US's geopolitical nightmare
2008-11-10The List: What McCain and Obama Didn’t Talk About
2008-11-11The Case for Restraint -- Foreign policy after George W. Bush
2008-11-14Towards a Grand Strategy for an Uncertain World -- Renewing Transatlantic Partnership
2009-06-13Remarks By The President On A New Beginning
2009-01-28When religions talk
2008-12-25India's Reckless Road to Washington -- Through Tel Aviv
2009-03-31Ambitions for Afghanistan down to earth -- Editorial
2009-04-13Pakistan To America: Back Off
2009-05-13NBC News' Meet The Press: Dick Cheney
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 2. Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2009-06-01Obama's Cairo Speech
2007-01-06The Islamabad Dilemma - Success in Afghanistan Depends on Success in Pakistan
2006-12-15Role of Media in Conflict
2007-01-25MIDDLE EAST - Timeline of recent developments
2007-01-24The price of hypocrisy
2007-01-27My Worst Moment As a Lawyer
2007-02-19Hating America
2007-02-20Transformational Diplomacy
2007-03-05HOW BRITAIN'S ARMAMENTS FUEL WAR AND POVERTY
2007-03-19Made in USA
2007-03-20'I've Got Nothing to Lose'
2007-03-21Chris Hedges: The Christian Right’s War on America
2007-03-24Is the American Empire on the Brink of Collapse?
2007-04-05U.S. to use al Qaeda suspect's words against him
2007-04-10Six Crises in Search of an Author
2007-04-17Human Rights Council Discusses Reports On Health, Right To Food And Human Rights Defenders
2007-04-12Cheney Fights for Detainee Policy -- As Pressure Mounts to Limit Handling Of Terror Suspects, He Holds Hard Line
2007-04-12A Conversation With Vladimir Bukovsky
2006-10-28The Failed Presidency of George W. Bush
2006-05-01Bush, in High-Tech Center, Urges Americans to Welcome Competition From India
2006-05-01Bush Rules Out a Nuclear Deal With Pakistanis
2006-09-09Clinton Administration Officials Assail ABC's 'The Path to 9/11'
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: East Asia and Pacific Overview
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2007-04-27INDEPTH: THE DALAI LAMA -- Tibet Timeline
2007-05-04US rebuffs Bin Laden 'truce call'
2007-05-10A Reporter At Large: In The Party Of God (Part II)
2007-05-23How terrorism finds root in the West
2007-05-30The great escape
2007-07-08Bin Laden's Fatwa
2007-06-28Outsourcing Torture -- The secret history of America’s “extraordinary rendition” program
2007-07-01Why the Future May Not Belong to Islam
2007-06-07The Global Weapons of Mass Destruction Threat: A Counter- Argument to the Western Interdisciplinary Viewpoint
2007-06-06Nato’s Islamists
2007-06-07Rights Groups Call for End to Secret Detentions
2007-06-17More Smoke on the Horizon in the Middle East War Theater
2007-09-07Understanding the U.S.-Israel Alliance: An Israeli Response to the Walt-Mearsheimer Claim
2007-09-17Commentary: Is 'terrorist threat' to America another Bush-Cheney fabrication?
2007-09-15Sept. 10 in Waziristan -- What Will Be Done About al-Qaeda's Camps?
2007-09-18The Shock Doctrine: Naomi Klein on the Rise of Disaster Capitalism
2007-09-13National Commission On Terrorist Attacks Upon The United States
2007-08-24The Challenge of Islam
2007-08-28The New Rules Of Engagement
2007-07-10Profile: President Pervez Musharraf
2007-07-14Londonistan Calling
2007-07-17Al-Qaida may use Iraqi network to attack U.S.
2007-07-26Bush ties Al Qaeda in Iraq to Sept. 11
2007-08-06Policy Claim: Pakistan … Send in the Replacements
2007-08-10The Role of Pakistan's Military Intelligence (ISI) in the September 11 Attacks
2007-08-09The general and the mullahs
2007-08-09Is Pakistan Likely to Become a Taliban State?
2007-08-08Rorschach and Awe -- The War on Terror
2007-08-14Editorial: Tread carefully after 60 ideologically mismatched years
2008-03-06"Victory Would be a Fata Morgana"
2008-03-03Mead: Bush Administration Gets Improving ‘Grades’ in First Year of Second Term’s Foreign Policy
2008-03-03Us and Them -- The Enduring Power of Ethnic Nationalism
2008-03-24Chalmers Johnson: “Nemesis: The Last Days of the American Republic”
2008-03-23Muslim's conversion conflict hits Vatican on Easter
2008-03-31BLOOD BROTHERS
2008-04-02Some Things Just Won't Change
2008-04-24Revamping American Grand Strategy
2008-05-04Rush Interviews Andrew McCarthy
2008-05-14NATO at a Crossroads
2008-05-19Walker's World: Bush with the pharaohs
2008-05-19Bush’s Speech Prods Middle East Leaders
2008-01-02Turkish accession to the European union: challenges and opportunities
2008-01-07In Musharraf’s Shadow, a New Hope for Pakistan Rises
2008-01-08High stakes in Kenya crisis for U.S. war on terror
2008-01-09Why I Believe Bush Must Go -- Nixon Was Bad. These Guys Are Worse
2008-01-07U.S. Considers New Covert Push Within Pakistan
2008-01-10Can Islam change?
2008-01-10A revenger's tragedy
2008-01-10Robert Fisk: They don't blame al-Qa'ida. They blame Musharraf
2007-12-22Clinton on Foreign Policy at University of Nebraska
2007-12-14Was There an Islamic "Genocide" of Hindus?
2007-12-15Why We Should Oppose an Independent Kosovo
2007-12-28Benazir Bhutto, 54, Weathered Political Storm -- Obituary
2007-12-27Policy Options Paper: Pakistan
2007-12-27Pakistan: Luck Running Out?
2007-12-29Pakistan Says Bhutto’s Death Has Qaeda Link
2007-12-29Jihadists and this disaster for us all
2007-12-29His Toughness Problem — and Ours
2007-12-27Pakistan After Bhutto
2007-12-27Jinnah – The Leader !
2007-12-27Former premier Benazir Bhutto assassinated in Pakistan
2007-12-24US aid to Pakistan diverted, squandered: report
2008-01-25US military: Taliban spring offensive unlikely in Afghanistan
2008-02-03A Modest Proposal for Middle East Peace
2008-01-21Strategic Communication
2008-02-09New Delhi's War Hysteria
2008-02-15Clinton Started CIA Rendition Program: Ex-agent
2008-02-17Melanie Phillips on the Archbishop of Canterbury and Islamic Sharia law in Britain
2008-02-18The Next Christianity
2008-02-21'America Alone: The End of the World as We Know It' -- A review
2008-02-22Three blind men confront the elephant that is this globalization era’s radical extremist reaction--and surprise! They all see a different beast!
2008-02-23The Two Faces of Saudi Arabia
2007-12-10Timeline: the al-Qaida tapes
2007-12-10Hill Briefed on Waterboarding in 2002
2007-12-12Jihad reconsidered
2007-12-13Bilderberg 2007 - Towards a One World Empire?
2007-11-21Pakistan’s Collapse, Our Problem