Posted by: zanshin, 2009-03-07 12:34

Story

Gaza homes destruction 'wanton'
2009-03-06 (Friday), BBC News
Human rights investigators say Israeli forces engaged in "wanton destruction" of Palestinian homes during the recent conflict in Gaza.

Amnesty International has told the BBC News website the methods used raised concerns about war crimes.

Israel's military said buildings were destroyed because of military "operational needs".

The Israeli Defense Forces said they operated in accordance with international law during the conflict.

However, the use of mines to destroy homes contradicted this claim, the head of the Amnesty International fact-finding mission to southern Israel and Gaza, Donatella Rovera, has argued.


“ The IDF emphasises that the terrorist organisation, Hamas, and its infrastructure were the target of Operation Cast Lead, and not the civilian population in Gaza ”
Israeli military statement
Israeli troops had to leave their vehicles to plant the mines, indicating that they faced no danger and that there was no military or operational justification, she said.

Breaking the Silence, an Israeli group that gathers and circulates the testimonies of Israeli soldiers, has also told the BBC News website that its findings from the Gaza war suggested many demolitions had been carried out when there was no immediate threat.

"From the testimonies that we've gathered, lots of demolitions - buildings demolished either by bulldozers or explosives - were done after the area was under Israeli control," said Yehuda Shaul, one of the group's members.

Destruction of civilian property is not illegal in itself under international law, but it must be justifiable on military grounds - for example if the building was booby trapped or being used as cover for enemy fighters.

Thousands of buildings were destroyed in the 22-day Israeli operation.

Some of them were police stations, mosques and government premises attacked in targeted airstrikes, in many cases with surrounding buildings left in tact.

Reduced to rubble

There were also whole neighbourhoods reduced to rubble in areas where the Israeli ground forces were present.


Ms Rovera said Amnesty International was concerned about "large scale destruction of homes and other civilian properties" during the conflict.

"The destruction was, in our view, and according to our findings, wanton destruction - it could not be justified on military grounds," she said.

Ms Rovera said her team found fragments of anti-tank mines in and around destroyed properties.

Their use was also consistent with remains of houses, collapsed in on themselves as if blown up from below, rather than destroyed from above as in an airstrike, she said.

Troops would have had to leave their armoured vehicles to plant them and rig up the detonators, she said.

"Unless those operating on the ground felt not just 100% but 200% secure - that the places were not booby trapped, that they wouldn't come under fire - they could not have got out of the vehicles," she said. "They would not have used that method."

"The use of the method tells us even more that there wasn't the kind of danger that might have made it lawful to destroy some of those properties," Ms Rovera said.


GAZA DESTRUCTION

14,000 homes
219 factories
240 schools UNDP estimates

"Wanton destruction on a large scale would qualify as a war crime," she said, adding that the practice was among several used in the conflict by both sides that Amnesty is concerned may constitute war crimes.
In one case visited by the BBC, six homes belonging to the extended family of Raed al-Atamna in the Izbit Abed Rabbo area, near the border with Israel, were destroyed.

Mr Atamna said a UN ordnance clearance team had found several mines in and around the remains of one of the homes.

He said he and his family had fled the area during the Israeli military operation, and returned to find their homes demolished.

'Substantial operational needs'

The IDF said buildings in the Gaza Strip were destroyed during Operation Cast Lead due to "substantial operational needs".

In a written statement, it said: "For example, buildings were either booby-trapped, located over tunnels, or fire was opened from within them in the direction of IDF soldiers.

"The terrorist organisations operated from within the civilian population, using them as a cover and made cynical use of the IDF's strict rules of engagement, opening fire from within civilian population centres, mosques, schools, hospitals and even private residences of citizens in the Gaza Strip.

"The troops were briefed and trained to avoid harming uninvolved civilians and did all they could to give warning in advance so that civilians could distance themselves from combat zones.

"The IDF emphasises that the terrorist organisation, Hamas, and its infrastructure were the target of Operation Cast Lead, and not the civilian population in Gaza."

A military source said the mines used do not detonate automatically and therefore do not represent a danger when left unexploded in the field.

© BBC MMIX

Comments


No comments yet.

Please login to post your comment.












All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Stories, Arguments and Comments are owned by the Poster.
The Rest copyright © 2007 Argumentations.com. All rights reserved. Argumentations.com provides material for research or educational purposes only. We do not warrant the correctness of its contents. The risk from using it lies entirely with the user. While using this site, you agree to have read and accepted our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Argumentations.com is far from perfect so if you have any critiques, questions, comments or problems about this site please tell us. Click here to send your feedback. And if you like Argumentations.com please link to this site. It will really help a lot.
   


Related statements

Date  
2009-03 "From the testimonies that we've gathered, lots of demolitions - buildings demolished either by bulldozers or explosives - were done after the area was under Israeli control."
-- Yehuda Shaul, member of Breaking the Silence, an Israeli group that gathers and circulates the testimonies of Israeli soldiers, told BBC News
2009-03 Israeli forces engaged in "wanton destruction" of Palestinian homes during the recent conflict in Gaza.
-- According to human rights investigators
2009-03 "Unless those operating on the ground felt not just 100% but 200% secure - that the places were not booby trapped, that they wouldn't come under fire - they could not have got out of the vehicles.
They would not have used that method
[of anti-tank mines. Troops would have had to leave their armoured vehicles to plant them and rig up the detonators].
The use of the method tells us even more that there wasn't the kind of danger that might have made it lawful to destroy some of those properties."
-- Donatella Rovera, the head of the Amnesty International fact-finding mission to southern Israel and Gaza
2009-03 Wanton destruction on a large scale would qualify as a war crime."
-- Donatella Rovera, the head of the Amnesty International fact-finding mission to southern Israel and Gaza
Buildings in the Gaza Strip were destroyed during Operation Cast Lead due to "substantial operational needs".
-- According to the IDF
Destruction of civilian property is not illegal in itself under international law, but it must be justifiable on military grounds - for example if the building was booby trapped or being used as cover for enemy fighters.
“The IDF emphasises that the terrorist organisation, Hamas, and its infrastructure were the target of Operation Cast Lead, and not the civilian population in Gaza.”
-- Israeli military statement

View other suggested stories

Date added 
2009-01-21Outcry Erupts Over Reports That Israel Used Phosphorus Arms on Gazans
2009-01-27Did Israel Commit War Crimes in Gaza?
2009-01-03Israel/Hamas: Civilians Must Not Be Targets
2009-01-11The limits of diplomacy
2009-01-13U.S. Branch of Amnesty Calls on Rice to Drop "Lopsided" Stance
2009-02-27Strong Indications of Israeli War Crimes -- A Report from Gaza
2009-05-22Averting Abuse of Universal Jurisdiction
2009-10-13The Goldstone Report: Killing The Messenger
2007-06-21Jimmy Carter says U.S. aims to split Palestinians
2007-12-14The Origin of the Palestine-Israel Conflict -- complete text
2008-05-19A Human Rights Crime In Gaza
2008-05-25Fmr. Israeli Foreign Minister Shlomo Ben Ami Debates Outspoken Professor Norman Finkelstein on Israel, the Palestinians, and the Peace Process
2008-06-21Jimmy Carter and Apartheid
2009-09-29Palestinians Call For Israel To Be 'punished' For Gaza Offensive
2009-07-04UN expert says Israeli seizure of aid ship a crime
2009-01-15Amnesty International's Anti-Israeli Complaint
2009-01-15Leading Israeli Scholar Avi Shlaim: Israel Committing “State Terror” in Gaza Attack, Preventing Peace
2008-12-30May We No Longer Be Silent -- America's Crimes "Never Happened"
2009-02-02Israel says Spain says it will amend war crimes law
2009-02-02Under the Black Flag -- Israeli War Crimes
2009-02-02Spain opens war crimes case against Israel
2009-02-02Spain investigates claims of Israeli crimes against humanity in Gaza
2008-12-06Slow-Motion Genocide in Occupied Palestine
2008-12-06Revoking Israel's UN Membership
2008-12-14Use of the Veto on United Nations Resolutions by the USA
2008-12-16UNHRC rapporteur denied entry to Israel
2008-12-29Stuart Littlewood
2008-08-21The Gaza concentration camp: ancient colonialism through a Nazi filter
2008-09-09Interview Norman Finkelstein: "We ask the ones who were kicked out of their homes, to recognise the legitimacy of the ones who kicked them out."
2008-09-25Power, Politics & Scholarship
2008-11-02Book Review: The Case for Palestine: An International Law Perspective
2008-06-22The Kiss of Death -- Olmert's Courtship of Abbas
2008-06-22Tutu plunges into heart of Israeli-Palestinian conflict
2008-06-22Hezbollah deal delayed over demand to include Palestinian prisoners
2008-06-23Gaza Truce Is a Sham, Say Analysts -- Israeli planning shaped by desire to attack Iran
2008-06-25The mega prison of Palestine
2008-06-25Shackled Warrior -- Israel in bondage -- An NRO Q&A
2008-05-27Carter says Israel has arsenal of 150 nuclear weapons
2008-05-28Human rights abuses seen up in Gaza and W.Bank
2008-05-31Is Israel Bound by International Law to Supply Utilities, Goods, and Services to Gaza?
2008-05-31The Diplomatic Dance with Hamas
2008-06-01What to Do About Gaza
2008-06-08Defense sources: Talk of major IDF operation in Gaza premature
2008-06-18EU slams Israeli threat against Syria
2008-05-23An Interview With Prof. Norman Finkelstein
2008-05-24UN: Gross violations by Israel of housing rights in Palestine
2008-01-04Bush presses on with Mideast diplomacy despite Gaza raids
2008-01-18Israeli attacks on Gaza hobble Abbas
2007-12-22Hamas admits to fatal Israeli bus bombings
2007-11-26Tragedy and Travesty at Annapolis
2007-10-07Palestinians launch longer-range rocket into Israel
2007-11-02As Israel grabs more West Bank territory -- Abbas lays out land for state
2007-05-23The six-day war is not over. Today, it brings the spectre of al-Qaida in Gaza
2007-05-22Israel pounds Gaza, Palestinian attack kills 1
2007-06-04We came, we shelled, we killed
2007-06-22Hamas Leader Warns Israel Not to Attack
2007-07-03Our Second Biggest Mistake in the Middle East
2007-07-15Israeli Apartheid is the Core of the Crisis
2007-07-15“Two States Or One State” -- Debate by Uri Avnery & Ilan Pappe
2007-08-19On Israel, America and AIPAC
2007-09-25Beneath the Hideous Veneer of "Security"
2007-10-01SAUDI ARABIA/US: Coming tensions
2006-09-11Blair and Abbas Discuss Idea of a Unity Government
2007-01-25MIDDLE EAST - Timeline of recent developments
2007-01-25Ariel Sharon - Milestones of his career
2007-01-25Arafat Timeline
2007-03-10Shattered Dreams of Peace - Timeline
2007-03-31The Second Lebanon War -- It probably won't be the last
2007-04-12The Eurabia Code
2007-05-16Reality Overtakes the Illusion of Unity in Gaza
2008-10-27The Rape of Palestine -- Hope Destroyed, Justice Denied
2008-09-15Scottish activist films Israeli navy shooting at Gaza fishermen
2008-09-15A New Strategy for the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
2008-08-31A Real Pro-Israel Policy Helps Palestine, Too
2008-08-20Israel to treat Gaza peace boats 'like pirates'
2008-08-21Truce barely eases Gaza embargo
2008-08-24Cutting out US role, new Egyptian-Saudi plan proposes inter-Arab force for Gaza
2008-08-18Here We Go 'Round the Mulberry Bush
2008-08-18Shame On Us
2008-08-20Israeli Government Recognizes “Humanitarian” Mission to Break the Siege of Gaza
2008-08-02The Zionist Plan of Stages
2008-12-29Washington bears guilt for Gaza war crimes
2008-12-27Scores Killed Across Gaza as Israel Strikes at Hamas
2008-12-20A short path, from Gaza to Somalia
2008-12-22Israeli leaders 'to topple Hamas'
2008-12-22Jenin: A model for the West bank?
2008-12-16Slouching toward a Palestinian Holocaust
2008-12-19Ceasefire in Gaza over, violence set to rise
2008-11-10The Time Has Come to Say These Things
2009-01-28Israel hits Gaza tunnels as U.S. envoy due
2009-01-22On Palestinian Question, Tough Choices for Obama
2009-01-22The Boss Has Gone Mad -- Livni's Smile
2009-01-23How Gaza became a Palestinian prison
2008-12-30The Gaza Ghetto and Western Cant -- Official Apathy
2008-12-30‘A Dubai on the Mediterranean’ -- Sara Roy on Gaza’s future
2008-12-30Israel's Attempted Endgame in Gaza -- Before Our Very Eyes
2009-01-01Memo for Obama
2009-01-01Israeli strike kills Hamas political leader
2009-01-11The hundred years' war
2009-01-11Gaza: the rights and wrongs
2009-01-04Biden's 'Obama Crisis' May Be A War Against Israel
2009-01-04Is the Real Target Hamas Rule?
2009-01-05Orwell, blinding tribalism, selective Terrorism, and Israel/Gaza
2009-01-15Clinton Expresses Plans For New World Approach
2009-01-18U.S. welcomes Gaza ceasefire, Iran says not enough
2009-01-06Rationalizing Gaza -- How they do it
2009-01-03Israel in Gaza: Right but not Smart
2009-01-11An inside story of how the US magnified Palestinian suffering
2009-02-21Dutch Gaza proposal angers Egypt
2009-03-02Hamas team arrives in Egypt for Gaza truce talks
2009-03-02U.S. senator visits Gaza
2009-03-02News Analysis: Israeli aggression has little leeway for retrogression
2009-03-02Backgrounder: Israel's ground offensives in Gaza since 2005
2009-03-02Cheney: Israel didn't seek U.S. green light on Gaza invasion
2009-06-16Netanyahu's speech vexes Arabs
2009-06-16Carter to show Hamas new vision of conflict resolution: sources
2009-07-06Rewards of Syrian diplomacy
2009-07-16Israeli soldiers say reckless force used in Gaza
2009-04-05Robert Fisk: Galloway a victim of Canada's baffling approach to fighting terror
2009-09-28Sliming Goldstone And His Report -- Confronting The G20
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 6 -- Terrorist Organizations
2007-05-06Palestinians reject US peace plan, Israel cool too
2007-05-06Palestinians divided over U.S. security plan
2007-05-08Hamas' Mickey Mouse: Teaching Kids to Hate and Kill
2007-05-10A Reporter At Large: In The Party Of God (Part II)
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2007-05-02EU Delegation Meets Hamas PM, Israel Protests
2007-04-10Six Crises in Search of an Author
2007-03-13Years of Strife and Lost Hope Scar Young Palestinians
2007-03-16The Arab Peace Initiative: This Time, Israel Is Missing an Historic Opportunity
2007-02-13More politics, less force
2007-02-13Diskin: Gaza going back to clan rule
2007-02-13Israel: The Alternative
2007-03-05HOW BRITAIN'S ARMAMENTS FUEL WAR AND POVERTY
2007-03-01ARAB COUNTRIES - GENERAL ANALYSIS
2007-03-09King Abdullah Calls for U.S. Help with Mideast Peace Plan
2007-01-25Lebanon - Background / Timeline
2007-01-16An Honest Man Refutes Propaganda - Carter's Inconvenient Truths
2006-12-11Urbanizing War/Militarizing Cities - The city as strategic site
2006-10-07Arafat Without Tears
2006-10-25US: world empire of chaos
2006-12-03Middle East hot spots merging
2006-09-05Over U.S. Objections, Israel Approves West Bank Homes
2006-09-07We Europeans must never forget that we created the Middle East conflict
2006-05-01U.N. Says Cuts in Palestinian Aid Could Lead to Crisis
2006-05-01Head High, Hamas Member Returns From Israeli Jail
2007-09-27Money trail to Hamas begins with Israeli banks
2007-09-19Israel Declares Gaza an ‘Enemy Entity’
2007-09-07Israel’s cost to the Arabs
2007-08-23Can't Stay the Course, Can't End the War, But We'll Call it Bipartisan
2007-08-26Power shifting in the Middle East
2007-08-01Gates, Rice hear Arab fears of U.S. withdrawal
2007-08-05Official: Most West Bank Gunmen Disarm
2007-07-15Hollow Land -- Architecture as Military Strategy
2007-07-25Arab League in Jerusalem for 1st Time
2007-07-30Bush's real agenda in Palestine
2007-07-04Rising to a New Generation of Global Challenges
2007-07-09Interview transcript: David Miliband
2007-07-09Her Jewish State
2007-07-09Miliband gives Iran nuclear warning
2007-06-25What's Behind the Arab-Israel Summit
2007-06-25Israel's 40 Years of Occupation: From Democratic State to Violent Oppressor
2007-06-061967: a war of miscalculation and misjudgment
2007-06-04History of failed peace talks
2007-06-04Palestinian rivals: Fatah & Hamas
2007-06-04Obstacles to peace: Borders and settlements
2007-05-28Israel's wasted victory
2007-05-28Forty years on
2007-06-04Obstacles to peace: Water
2007-05-23Palestine: Forty Years of Occupation
2007-05-21Israel pounds Gaza, threatens to kill Hamas leaders
2007-06-20Hamas wants Israel to starve Gaza
2007-06-22Al Qaeda Strikes Back
2007-06-19Comparing US & Palestine homicide rates
2007-06-08Leaving the Zionist ghetto
2007-06-13Let Palestine Split Into Two -- Opinion
2007-06-13Arabic Under Fire - MEMRI putting words in the mouths of babes
2007-06-14Abbas declares state of emergency as Hamas overrruns Gaza
2007-11-08If This Peace Process Fails
2007-11-16The Threat of Maritime Terrorism to Israel
2007-10-08Israel minister draws fire over Jerusalem division call
2007-10-09SYRIA: Regime interests dictate regional policies
2007-10-12Hamas leader warns Abbas against peace concessions
2007-10-12One reason for the absence of peace
2007-10-20Seeking a pragmatic solution
2007-11-26Bush launches biggest Mideast peace bid
2007-11-22The United States’ new backyard
2007-11-15Abbas calls on Gazans to 'get rid of' Hamas
2007-11-19Israel is the Key to Bush's Iraq Strategy -- Models of Occupation
2007-11-27Iran Casts Big Shadow on Mideast Talks
2007-12-07A new Chinese red line over Iran
2007-12-22Angry Palestinians vow revenge at funeral of "engineer"
2007-12-22Palestinian bomb suspect killed in Gaza blast
2008-02-04Arming the Middle East
2008-02-05The radicals are rising
2008-02-12Israel's "next logical step"
2008-01-06Israeli Fuel Cuts Force Gaza Blackouts
2008-01-07Abbas to Prod Bush on West Bank Settlements
2008-01-09Bush in Israel on Mideast peace drive
2008-01-09At Gaza’s Edge, Israelis Fear Rockets’ Whine
2008-01-11After Iraq
2008-01-14Mid-East talks on 'core issues'
2008-01-15At least 16 dead as Gaza violence heats up
2008-05-23As Israelis Celebrate Independence and Palestinians Mark the “Nakba,” a Debate with Benny Morris, Saree Makdisi and Norman Finkelstein
2008-05-19Bin Laden urges Muslims to fight Gaza closure
2008-04-29Israel is suppressing a secret it must face
2008-05-05Educational Geopolitics and the Settler University in Ariel
2008-05-07Image and Reality -- An Interview with Norman Finkelstein
2008-04-10Eretz Israel HaShlema / Greater Israel
2008-04-22The March to War: Israel Prepares for War against Lebanon and Syria
2008-02-23The Two Faces of Saudi Arabia
2008-02-29Holy depressing
2008-03-04The Israeli Recipe For 2008: Genocide in Gaza, Ethnic Cleansing in the West Bank
2008-06-14A Year Under Hamas Alters Life in Gaza
2008-06-14Israel-Hamas Peace (Quietly) at Hand?
2008-06-11Palestinians and Israelis Forging Bonds of Peace in Santa Fe
2008-06-01What is the Mission in the Gaza Strip?
2008-06-05Remarks By John McCain at AIPAC
2008-06-05Arab Summit: Israeli actions against Palestinians 'war crimes'
2008-05-31Israel at Sixty: Asymmetry, Vulnerability, and the Search for Security
2008-05-31The Palestinian Refugee Issue: Rhetoric vs. Reality
2008-05-23The Camp David II Negotiations: How Dennis Ross Proved the Palestinians Aborted the Peace Process
2008-05-27Palestinian, Iraqi, Afghan, Biofuel and Climate Genocides – Silence Kills and Silence is Complicity
2008-06-25The Jordanian Disengagement: Causes and Effects
2008-06-24The Iran Trap
2008-06-22Editorial: Tutu in Gaza
2008-06-21The war's seventh day
2008-06-21Shulamit Aloni: There IS Apartheid in Israel