Posted by: zanshin, 2009-06-17 12:13

Story

Arab leaders criticize Netanyahu's peace offer

2009-06-16 (Tuesday), Ya Libnan
Amman - Arab leaders, both friends and foes of Israel, sharply criticized on Monday the prescription to peace unveiled Sunday night by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.


Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, one of the few Arab leaders with diplomatic ties with Israel, said Mr. Netanyahu's words "scuttled" chances to end the conflict, a harsh reaction that could complicate President Barack Obama's efforts to push a solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Israeli officials have emphasized that Mr. Netanyahu's acceptance of the creation of a Palestinian state in the speech marked a major shift from his previous policies both as leader in the late-1990s and as an opposition parliamentarian. White House officials have expressed cautious optimism for that stance, calling the Israeli position a good first step.

But Arab diplomats said they were disappointed with the tone of the address, calling Mr. Netanyahu's speech deeply ideological. They also were concerned over the narrow list of topics covered in the 28-minute speech. The Israeli leader did not refer to the Arab's own peace initiative that promises recognition of Israel in exchange for territorial withdrawal and its compromise on the other core issues such as the status of Jerusalem and the issue of refugees. Nor did he commit himself to removing settlements in the West Bank, something that both the White House and the Arab world see as an impediment to a two-state solution.

Arab diplomats said they would be watching closely to see what next steps the White House would take. They said they want to see if President Obama tones down his rhetoric toward Israel or keeps the promise he made during his Cairo address earlier this month to ensure Israelis adhered to their own set of responsibilities to achieve peace.

"Clearly now the ball is in Washington's court. We will now see if [the Obama administration] is serious about being even-handed or not," one diplomat said.

Mr. Netanyahu demanded on Sunday that the Palestinians accept Israel as a Jewish nation as a precondition to statehood, a stance that would mean their caving in on a core tenant of negotiations until this point: the right of return for Palestinian refugees made homeless and stateless during Israel's war of independence.

The statement drew outrage from Israel's closest Arab ally, Egypt. Mr. Mubarak, who prides itself as a mediator in Palestinian issues and a close U.S. ally, said he had urged Mr. Netanyahu in his anticipated speech on Sunday to accept picking up peace talks where they had broken off instead of changing the parameters to achieve peace. That would have sent a message that the Israelis were serious about solving the two-decade-long standoff regarding the establishment of a Palestinian state, Arab diplomats said.

The bedrock of peace talks has been that Israeli withdrawals from territory it gained in the 1967 Arab-israeli War in exchange for peace while the two sides negotiate a solution to issues like refugees, Jerusalem and settlements.

The uproar from even the countries with close relations with Israel underscores how divisive the issues dividing the Palestinians and Israelis are -- as well as how important tone and perception of good will is to kick start a new peace push.

<a href="http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124509630599216151.html"> WSJ </a>

© Ya Libnan 2008

Comments


No comments yet.

Please login to post your comment.













All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Stories, Arguments and Comments are owned by the Poster.
The Rest copyright © 2007 Argumentations.com. All rights reserved. Argumentations.com provides material for research or educational purposes only. We do not warrant the correctness of its contents. The risk from using it lies entirely with the user. While using this site, you agree to have read and accepted our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Argumentations.com is far from perfect so if you have any critiques, questions, comments or problems about this site please tell us. Click here to send your feedback. And if you like Argumentations.com please link to this site. It will really help a lot.
   

Tags

Arab,   Egypt,   Hosni Mubarak,   Israel,   Netanyahu,   Obama,   War,  

Related statements

No results

View other suggested stories

Date added 
2009-06-01Obama's Cairo Speech
2009-06-07The Wages of Hubris and Vengeance -- The Future of Israel and the Decline of the American Empire
2009-06-07Obama in Cairo: High Words, Low Truths
2009-06-12Obama calls for new beginning between US, Muslims
2009-06-16Netanyahu's speech vexes Arabs
2009-09-12Promises Unfulfilled 100 Days After Obama's Cairo Speech
2007-03-05Timeline: al-Qaida
2007-03-27Our World: Condi's embrace of jihadist 'peace'
2007-03-31The Second Lebanon War -- It probably won't be the last
2007-04-02From the Wonderful Folks Who Brought You Iraq
2007-04-15Eye on Iran, Rivals Pursuing Nuclear Power
2007-04-17Olmert says ready for talks based on Saudi plan
2007-06-22Al Qaeda Strikes Back
2007-07-31Franco – Arab Ties Could Yet Survive Sarkozy’s U-Turn
2007-11-13The Deadly Embrace
2008-05-19Walker's World: Bush with the pharaohs
2008-06-25Shackled Warrior -- Israel in bondage -- An NRO Q&A
2009-01-11The hundred years' war
2009-01-24Thus Sprach Barack: Pouring Acid on Gaza's Wounds
2009-02-02Freedom Beats A Global Retreat
2009-02-08One on One: 'With no likelihood of US use of force, that leaves Israel'
2009-06-16Netanyahu's speech disappoints Palestinians
2009-06-15U.S. shows flexiblility on settlements, foregoes demand for complete construction freeze
2009-06-28Israel, Egypt negotiate terms of new Gaza truce
2009-07-07Aluf Benn / Netanyahu must remember U.S. is stronger than Israel
2009-06-13Remarks By The President On A New Beginning
2009-06-07Obama's give-and-take deal
2009-06-06Israeli media have mixed reactions to Obama's Cairo speech
2009-05-11King Abdullah in Mid-East warning
2009-02-07Israel to Obama: hold Iran's feet to fire, or else
2009-01-22On Palestinian Question, Tough Choices for Obama
2009-01-04Biden's 'Obama Crisis' May Be A War Against Israel
2009-01-05Barack Obama’s obsession with Islam
2009-01-05Which Muslim capital will Barack Obama choose?
2008-12-30The Gaza Ghetto and Western Cant -- Official Apathy
2009-01-06Commentary: Israel's endgame
2009-01-15Leading Israeli Scholar Avi Shlaim: Israel Committing “State Terror” in Gaza Attack, Preventing Peace
2008-06-25HOW HEZBOLLAH DEFEATED ISRAEL -- PART 3: The political
2008-06-26Jerusalem: The Final Frontier
2008-07-05Symposium: Israel's Test
2008-07-14Sarkozy, Mubarak launch Union for Mediterranean
2008-05-19Egypt: On the Brink of Revolution?
2008-05-19Bush’s Speech Prods Middle East Leaders
2008-05-25Fmr. Israeli Foreign Minister Shlomo Ben Ami Debates Outspoken Professor Norman Finkelstein on Israel, the Palestinians, and the Peace Process
2008-05-15Commentary: Iran's pawns move
2008-05-28The other face of Mobarak's Egypt: Is Washington Being Misadvised About Egypt?
2008-06-11The History of the House of Rothschild
2008-01-11After Iraq
2008-01-17President Bush Wraps Up Middle East Tour On Positive Note In Egypt
2008-02-04Arming the Middle East
2008-02-09Egyptian President Views Gaza Border Crisis, Iran Ties, Mideast
2008-08-22Arab world fears an Iran war may be impending
2008-08-24Cutting out US role, new Egyptian-Saudi plan proposes inter-Arab force for Gaza
2008-09-03A ticking Arab time bomb
2008-10-02U.S. Not Winning War on Terror -- Special Report
2008-10-08Iran’s Secret Bargain With Bush?
2008-10-24The World Around Russia: 2017 -- An Outlook for the Midterm Future
2008-11-07Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2008-11-08Obama picks pro-Israel hardliner for top post
2008-11-13Between Hope and Reality -- An Open Letter to Barack Obama
2008-12-06Obama's War Cabinet
2008-12-29Washington bears guilt for Gaza war crimes
2007-11-12Rabbi Ovadia Yosef And His "culture War" In Israel
2007-11-12NATO Expands into Arab South
2007-11-21US issues invitations for Nov 27 Mideast peace meet
2007-11-21Bush to host key Mideast peace conference Nov 27
2007-11-25Egypt’s Leader Endorses Peace Meeting
2007-11-26Tragedy and Travesty at Annapolis
2007-12-14The Origin of the Palestine-Israel Conflict -- complete text
2007-12-18Turkey's EU Membership's Possible Impacts on the Middle East
2008-01-03Is “Brotherhood” with America Possible?*
2007-08-05The End of Cowboy Diplomacy
2007-08-19Huge Human Cost Of Israel But Interim Peace Is Possible
2007-08-24Israel's Jewish problem in Tehran
2007-09-25Beneath the Hideous Veneer of "Security"
2007-07-31Why Did the Cairene Cross the Road?
2007-08-01Gates, Rice hear Arab fears of U.S. withdrawal
2007-07-22Iran's Renewed Threats to Take Over the Arab Gulf States
2007-07-04Lessons of the October War
2007-07-15“Two States Or One State” -- Debate by Uri Avnery & Ilan Pappe
2007-06-22KEY EVENTS - Brief Chronology of the 1967 Six-Day War
2007-06-22Symposium: Strategies of Death
2007-06-19Vanishing Christians of the Mideast -- The Silent Exodus
2007-06-19George Soros – Bush America needs de-Nazification
2007-06-25Sinai Bedouin, silent no more, demand justice
2007-06-25What's Behind the Arab-Israel Summit
2007-06-12A cease-fire won't get Israel what it wants
2007-06-14Analysis - North Lebanon fertile ground for Sunni militants
2007-06-16African Gothic
2007-06-17More Smoke on the Horizon in the Middle East War Theater
2007-06-17Welcome to 'Palestine'
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 5 -- Terrorist Safe Havens (7120 Report)
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 6 -- Terrorist Organizations
2007-05-03Sharia Crisis in Nigeria
2007-05-05WHY IRAN WILL HAVE THE BOMB
2007-05-11Waning Chances for Stability -- Least Bad Options in a Failed, War-Torn State
2007-05-16No-goodniks and the Palestinian shootout
2007-05-23Palestine: Forty Years of Occupation
2007-05-28Israel's wasted victory
2007-05-28Forty years on
2007-05-30The great escape
2007-05-31The Case for Bombing Iran
2007-06-01The Importance of Being Lucid
2007-06-04How 1967 defined the Middle East
2007-06-061967: a war of miscalculation and misjudgment
2007-06-04Obstacles to peace: Borders and settlements
2007-06-08Islam and Liberal Democracy: A Historical Overview
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2007-04-12Humiliation of Muslims and the coming Siege of Vienna
2007-04-12The Eurabia Code
2007-04-13Analysis: Arabian Medicis
2007-04-14Olmert invites ‘all Arab leaders’ to summit
2007-04-17Commission Adopts Resolutions On Combating Defamation Of Religions; Right To Development
2007-03-29Interview: Jimmy Carter -- Nobel Prize for Peace
2007-03-31EU agrees to deal with non-Hamas Palestinians
2007-04-04The Next World Order
2007-04-04Breaking Ranks -- What turned Brent Scowcroft against the Bush Administration?
2007-04-07FOREIGN RELATIONS: Marginalised by changing dynamics
2007-03-29Saudi king calls for end to Palestinian blockade
2007-03-20Egypt's Hope to Steal an Israeli City
2007-03-21Chris Hedges—Inside Egypt
2007-03-08Two faces of Arab intellectuals
2007-03-09Tantawi: France has right to ban hijab
2007-03-09Tantawi's Tantrum
2007-03-09Assembly, Opening Debate On Question Of Palestine, Hears Call For Enhanced UN Involvement In Current Middle East Situation
2007-03-10Shattered Dreams of Peace - Timeline
2007-03-15Mohammedanism
2007-03-16The Arab Peace Initiative: This Time, Israel Is Missing an Historic Opportunity
2007-03-16President Bush Calls for New Palestinian Leadership
2007-03-16Olmert unfazed by Egypt's plans to build nuclear plants
2007-03-19Made in USA
2007-01-24The price of hypocrisy
2007-01-24President Bush’s State of the Union Address
2007-01-25MIDDLE EAST - Timeline of recent developments
2007-01-25Ariel Sharon - Milestones of his career
2007-01-25Arafat Timeline
2007-01-25Make War Your Friend, Part I
2007-02-13Israel: The Alternative
2007-02-19Hating America
2007-03-01ARAB COUNTRIES - GENERAL ANALYSIS
2006-04-20The Next Iraqi War? Sectarianism and Civil Conflict
2006-08-21Why Bush should go to Tel Aviv - and confront Iran
2006-08-29The Middle East peace process has been the longest of disappointments
2006-08-29Saudi foreign minister calls for Arab League revamp
2006-09-02State of Schizophrenia
2006-09-03Transcript - President Bush's Speech
2006-09-12The Nation That Fell to Earth
2006-09-17Triple-pronged Jihad -- Military, Economic and Cultural
2006-11-26Islam, Terror and the Second Nuclear Age
2007-01-08Changing Strategies, Changing Allies - Bush Capitulates To Reality In The Middle East
2009-05-13NBC News' Meet The Press: Dick Cheney
2009-04-14Gulf war jitters -- Commentary
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 2. Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2009-05-22The Revenge of Geography
2009-05-22The Historical Roots of the Anti-Israel Positions of Liberal Protestant Churches -- Interview with Hans Jansen
2009-02-21Binyamin Netanyahu warns of Iranian nuclear threat
2009-03-02Chronology of major talks on Mideast peace
2009-03-17U.S. to preheat "engagement policy" in Middle East
2009-07-05'This Week' Transcript: EXCLUSIVE: Vice President Joe Biden
2009-07-06Rewards of Syrian diplomacy
2009-07-18Palestine's land Islamic endowment can never be dropped:Hamas minister
2009-07-20The painful cost to Israel of its settler adventure
2009-06-28Akiva Eldar / Don't tempt us with peace, scare us with its absence
2009-07-03Russia's New Scramble for Africa -- Moscow attempts to rebuild its sphere of influence in the African continent
2009-06-15Carter: Netanyahu speech created new obstacles to peace
2009-06-15Obama: Netanyahu's speech could jumpstart peace talks
2009-06-15A call from the Arab Street...
2009-06-15Israel's Netanyahu backs demilitarized Palestinian state
2009-06-15U.S. hails Israeli PM's foreign policy speech
2009-06-16Israeli press views Netanyahu as "unifier"
2009-06-16Lebanese president calls for Arab unity after Netanyahu speech
2009-06-17The narrow strategic thinking of pro-Ahmadinejad Israelis
2009-06-17Lieberman to Clinton: Israel won't freeze settlements
2009-09-28Sliming Goldstone And His Report -- Confronting The G20
2009-10-15Fearsome Words? -- A Suppressed Talk On The Israel/palestine Conflict
2006-12-30Saddam’s Rise and Fall
2007-01-09Despite their shoddy track record on Iraq analysis, O'Reilly trusts only "my military analysts
2007-01-14Natural Resources are Fuelling a New Cold War
2007-01-16Rice Speaks Softly in Egypt, Avoiding Democracy Push