Posted by: zanshin, 2009-07-20 02:07

Story

The painful cost to Israel of its settler adventure

Bradley Burston, 2009-07-20 (Monday), Haaretz
As friction between the Obama administration and Israel mounts over Washington's repeated calls for a freeze on settlement construction, anxious supporters of Israel's West Bank settlement enterprise ask one question with ever greater urgency and frequency:

Why should settlers have to pay the price for peace between Israel and the Palestinians?

The question is intended to be rhetorical, meant to dismiss and deflect pressure to curb expansion of West Bank enclaves.

But in a real sense, it is precisely the question of the moment. Why, in fact, should settlers be made to pay the price for peace?

The answer, in short: Because of what the settlement movement has cost us, cost Israel. And because of what it is costing Israel now.

1. The cost in dollars

The settlement movement has cost Israel some $100 billion over the past 40 years.

Setting aside the considerable waste and graft in building projects in the West Bank and Gaza, the cost to Israel's development has been incalculable. Settlement in remote areas has siphoned off critically needed funds for investment in employment, infrastructure, housing and social welfare in central Israel, the Galillee and the Negev.

Huge expenditures on West Bank road construction, including parallel highways intended only for use by Israelis, and roads built at great expense to remote and often illegal settlements, have taken a human toll as well. They have put off the upgrading of dangerous roads [designated "red highways"] within Israel, adding materially to one of the country's most lethal problems. Last year more than 440 people died on Israel's highways, more than 12 times the number of Israelis killed in terror attacks.

2. The cost to Israel's security

For decades, the enormous burdens of guarding settlements, policing roadblocks and maintaining the far-reaching bureaucracy of occupation have robbed the IDF of vitally needed resources of time and funding for military training.

In recent months, as Haaretz military commentator Amir Oren has reported, Prime Minister Netanyahu's wrangling with President Obama over settlement construction has been doing damage to the IDF's capability to face the threat posed by Iran.

3. The cost to Israeli democracy and the rule of law

The unwillingness of the settlement movement to brook compromise, even when in direct defiance of national consensus, and its explicit threats to exploit Israel's precarious political system to topple any democratically elected government which makes significant progress in negotiations with the Palestinians, places the very nature of Israeli democracy in doubt.

The double standard which for decades has favored settlers with inexpensive housing, heavily subsidized social services, and blind-eye building permits has long been accompanied by a kid-gloves approach regarding settler violence against Palestinians and their property.


4. The cost to Israel's diplomatic credibility

Both in established settlements and in outposts acknowledged by Israel as illegal, settlers and settlement planners have covertly bent and distorted zoning procedures, military directives, and government decrees in order to boost settlement, block Palestinian construction, agriculture, and access to employment, and effectively neutralize measures intended to foster Israeli-Palestinian peace progress.

Measures aimed at driving a secure wedge between settlers and Palestinians have had the effect of tarnishing Israel's international image, and have kept many nations from normalizing and strengthening diplomatic ties with Israel.

The settlers' rejection of all territorial compromise renders moot all proposals similar to the Arab League peace initiative.

5. The cost to Israel's relationship with the U.S.

With every move of ostentatious defiance mounted by the Netanyahu government, the Obama administration finds the Palestinian Authority a more reliant, cooperative, and businesslike partner for diplomacy and West Bank security.

The gratuitous machismo characterizing many of the declarations of right-wing parties, in particular the shrill back-benchers of Netanyahu's Likud and members of Avigdor Lieberman's indictment-shadowed Yisrael Beiteinu, has done little to win domestic backing in Israel, but has landed with dramatic and destructive effect in Washington.

Comments


No comments yet.

Please login to post your comment.













All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Stories, Arguments and Comments are owned by the Poster.
The Rest copyright © 2007 Argumentations.com. All rights reserved. Argumentations.com provides material for research or educational purposes only. We do not warrant the correctness of its contents. The risk from using it lies entirely with the user. While using this site, you agree to have read and accepted our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Argumentations.com is far from perfect so if you have any critiques, questions, comments or problems about this site please tell us. Click here to send your feedback. And if you like Argumentations.com please link to this site. It will really help a lot.
   

Tags

Agriculture,   Arab,   democracy,   diplomacy,   Gaza,   Iran,   Israel,   military,   Netanyahu,   Obama,   Palestine,   Palestinian-Israeli Conflict,  

Related statements

No results

View other suggested stories

Date added 
2007-03-31The Second Lebanon War -- It probably won't be the last
2007-07-15“Two States Or One State” -- Debate by Uri Avnery & Ilan Pappe
2008-12-29Washington bears guilt for Gaza war crimes
2009-01-04Biden's 'Obama Crisis' May Be A War Against Israel
2009-06-07Obama in Cairo: High Words, Low Truths
2009-07-06Rewards of Syrian diplomacy
2007-07-09Her Jewish State
2007-06-22Al Qaeda Strikes Back
2007-07-03Our Second Biggest Mistake in the Middle East
2007-03-01ARAB COUNTRIES - GENERAL ANALYSIS
2007-08-19On Israel, America and AIPAC
2007-09-25Beneath the Hideous Veneer of "Security"
2007-11-13The Deadly Embrace
2007-12-14The Origin of the Palestine-Israel Conflict -- complete text
2009-06-16Netanyahu's speech vexes Arabs
2009-06-13Remarks By The President On A New Beginning
2009-06-01Obama's Cairo Speech
2009-06-07The Wages of Hubris and Vengeance -- The Future of Israel and the Decline of the American Empire
2009-06-15Israel's Netanyahu backs demilitarized Palestinian state
2009-01-06Rationalizing Gaza -- How they do it
2009-01-11The hundred years' war
2009-01-11An inside story of how the US magnified Palestinian suffering
2009-01-15Leading Israeli Scholar Avi Shlaim: Israel Committing “State Terror” in Gaza Attack, Preventing Peace
2009-01-18U.S. welcomes Gaza ceasefire, Iran says not enough
2008-12-30The Gaza Ghetto and Western Cant -- Official Apathy
2009-01-22On Palestinian Question, Tough Choices for Obama
2009-01-24Thus Sprach Barack: Pouring Acid on Gaza's Wounds
2008-11-10The Time Has Come to Say These Things
2008-09-15A New Strategy for the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
2008-09-20How We Misunderstand Terrorism
2008-09-25Power, Politics & Scholarship
2008-02-04Arming the Middle East
2008-02-26Fitzgerald: Islam for Infidels, Part Two
2008-06-24The Iran Trap
2008-06-25The Jordanian Disengagement: Causes and Effects
2008-06-25Shackled Warrior -- Israel in bondage -- An NRO Q&A
2007-12-18Turkey's EU Membership's Possible Impacts on the Middle East
2008-01-11After Iraq
2007-11-12NATO Expands into Arab South
2007-11-11In the Wake of War: Geo-strategy, Terrorism, Oil Markets, and Domestic Politics
2007-11-26Tragedy and Travesty at Annapolis
2007-11-28Israel and Palestinians Set Goal of a Treaty in 2008
2007-08-24The Challenge of Islam
2007-03-10Shattered Dreams of Peace - Timeline
2007-03-27Our World: Condi's embrace of jihadist 'peace'
2006-12-03Middle East hot spots merging
2006-12-06Transcript - The Nomination Hearing for Robert M. Gates
2007-01-16An Honest Man Refutes Propaganda - Carter's Inconvenient Truths
2007-01-25MIDDLE EAST - Timeline of recent developments
2007-01-25Ariel Sharon - Milestones of his career
2007-02-13Israel: The Alternative
2006-10-05Symposium: Why the Mullahs Murdered Atefeh Rajabi
2007-07-02Zionist Plan for the Middle East
2007-07-10It’s Time for a Declaration of Independence From Israel
2007-07-04Rising to a New Generation of Global Challenges
2007-07-12House Armed Services Committee Global Security Assessment Statement For The Record
2007-07-30Bush's real agenda in Palestine
2007-04-02From the Wonderful Folks Who Brought You Iraq
2007-04-12The Eurabia Code
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 5 -- Terrorist Safe Havens (7120 Report)
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 6 -- Terrorist Organizations
2007-05-27When oil and water mix
2007-05-27Commentary: Islamic deja vu
2007-06-04We came, we shelled, we killed
2007-06-061967: a war of miscalculation and misjudgment
2008-06-26Jerusalem: The Final Frontier
2008-07-02Zionism’s Dead End
2008-07-31Foreign Minister Jonas Gahr Støre delivers speech at Harvard University
2008-05-15Commentary: Iran's pawns move
2008-05-25Fmr. Israeli Foreign Minister Shlomo Ben Ami Debates Outspoken Professor Norman Finkelstein on Israel, the Palestinians, and the Peace Process
2008-05-31The Diplomatic Dance with Hamas
2008-06-05Remarks By John McCain at AIPAC
2008-06-11Deadly Fallout From Obama's Groveling Before Israel Lobby
2008-06-11The History of the House of Rothschild
2008-06-22The Kiss of Death -- Olmert's Courtship of Abbas
2008-06-21Jimmy Carter and Apartheid
2008-04-10Imperial Israel: The Nile-to-Euphrates Calumny
2008-05-05Educational Geopolitics and the Settler University in Ariel
2008-10-22Omid Safi - Who Put Hate in My Sunday Paper?
2008-10-24The World Around Russia: 2017 -- An Outlook for the Midterm Future
2008-09-18US Genocide in Iraq
2008-08-15The Lobby Like No Other -- Wants a War Like No Other
2008-08-21The Gaza concentration camp: ancient colonialism through a Nazi filter
2008-11-18Dual Loyalties Will Doom Obama -- The Blue and White Elephant in the Oval Office
2008-11-23The American Mission?
2008-12-05Obama must rescue the two-state solution
2008-12-06Revoking Israel's UN Membership
2008-12-06Obama's War Cabinet
2009-01-23How Gaza became a Palestinian prison
2009-01-22The Boss Has Gone Mad -- Livni's Smile
2009-02-07Israel to Obama: hold Iran's feet to fire, or else
2009-02-08One on One: 'With no likelihood of US use of force, that leaves Israel'
2008-12-30May We No Longer Be Silent -- America's Crimes "Never Happened"
2009-01-01Memo for Obama
2009-01-15Clinton Expresses Plans For New World Approach
2009-01-06Commentary: Israel's endgame
2009-06-15More Israelis support two-state solution after Obama's Cairo speech
2009-06-15Carter: Netanyahu speech created new obstacles to peace
2009-06-15Obama: Netanyahu's speech could jumpstart peace talks
2009-06-15U.S. shows flexiblility on settlements, foregoes demand for complete construction freeze
2009-06-12Obama calls for new beginning between US, Muslims
2009-06-13U.S. trying to push for peace between Israel, Syria
2009-06-07Obama's give-and-take deal
2009-06-06Israeli media have mixed reactions to Obama's Cairo speech
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 --
2009-05-22The Revenge of Geography
2009-05-22Averting Abuse of Universal Jurisdiction
2009-06-16Israeli press views Netanyahu as "unifier"
2009-06-16Lebanese president calls for Arab unity after Netanyahu speech
2009-06-28Israel, Egypt negotiate terms of new Gaza truce
2009-03-17U.S. to preheat "engagement policy" in Middle East
2009-04-14Gulf war jitters -- Commentary
2009-09-28Sliming Goldstone And His Report -- Confronting The G20
2007-06-01The Importance of Being Lucid
2007-06-04Obstacles to peace: Water
2007-05-28Forty years on
2007-05-28Martin Van Creveld: Israel the Mad Dog
2007-05-23The six-day war is not over. Today, it brings the spectre of al-Qaida in Gaza
2007-05-06Palestinians reject US peace plan, Israel cool too
2007-05-10A Reporter At Large: In The Party Of God (Part II)
2007-05-17Rehabilitating US Imperialism
2007-04-01'We Warned the United States'
2007-04-04Breaking Ranks -- What turned Brent Scowcroft against the Bush Administration?
2007-03-29Interview: Jimmy Carter -- Nobel Prize for Peace
2007-04-17Human Rights Council Discusses Reports On Health, Right To Food And Human Rights Defenders
2007-04-17Commission Adopts Resolutions On Combating Defamation Of Religions; Right To Development
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2007-07-31Franco – Arab Ties Could Yet Survive Sarkozy’s U-Turn
2007-08-01Gates, Rice hear Arab fears of U.S. withdrawal
2007-07-25Arab League in Jerusalem for 1st Time
2007-07-27To Check Syria, U.S. Explores Bond With Muslim Brothers
2007-07-08Bin Laden's Fatwa
2007-07-09Interview transcript: David Miliband
2007-07-13The New York Times Surrenders -- A monument to defeatism on the editorial page
2007-06-26Empire strikes back
2007-06-19George Soros – Bush America needs de-Nazification
2007-06-22Symposium: Strategies of Death
2007-06-25What's Behind the Arab-Israel Summit
2007-06-08Political Islam
2007-06-14Abbas declares state of emergency as Hamas overrruns Gaza
2007-06-17More Smoke on the Horizon in the Middle East War Theater
2007-06-17Welcome to 'Palestine'
2007-06-19Vanishing Christians of the Mideast -- The Silent Exodus
2006-10-07Arafat Without Tears
2006-09-12The Nation That Fell to Earth
2006-05-01Political Islam -- Forty shades of green
2006-05-01Israeli Election Campaign Starts in Earnest
2006-08-21Why Bush should go to Tel Aviv - and confront Iran
2006-09-02Abrams in Jerusalem
2007-02-13More politics, less force
2007-01-25Arafat Timeline
2007-01-25Make War Your Friend, Part I
2007-01-08Changing Strategies, Changing Allies - Bush Capitulates To Reality In The Middle East
2007-03-16The Arab Peace Initiative: This Time, Israel Is Missing an Historic Opportunity
2007-03-19Made in USA
2007-03-09Assembly, Opening Debate On Question Of Palestine, Hears Call For Enhanced UN Involvement In Current Middle East Situation
2007-03-09King Abdullah Calls for U.S. Help with Mideast Peace Plan
2007-02-19Chomsky on Iran, Iraq, and the Rest of the World
2007-08-26Power shifting in the Middle East
2007-08-23Can't Stay the Course, Can't End the War, But We'll Call it Bipartisan
2007-09-15Bush's tangled arms deal
2007-09-07Israel’s cost to the Arabs
2007-09-08Does independence beckon?
2007-11-27Iran Casts Big Shadow on Mideast Talks
2007-11-28Text of Bush’s Remarks at Annapolis Conference
2007-11-26Bush launches biggest Mideast peace bid
2007-11-20The Neoconservative Moment
2007-11-20Whose War?
2007-11-22The United States’ new backyard
2007-11-11The Next Act -- Is a damaged Administration less likely to attack Iran, or more?
2007-11-08If This Peace Process Fails
2007-11-13Remembering Yitzhak Rabin
2007-11-13The new wars of religion
2007-10-01SAUDI ARABIA/US: Coming tensions
2007-10-03The Iraqi Balfour Declaration?
2007-10-03Why the United States Invaded Iraq and is Now Thinking About Invading Iran
2007-10-09SYRIA: Regime interests dictate regional policies
2007-10-20Seeking a pragmatic solution
2007-10-22The Secret History of the Impending War with Iran That the White House Doesn't Want You to Know
2008-01-09Bush in Israel on Mideast peace drive
2007-12-20For Israel's Arab Citizens, Isolation and Exclusion
2007-12-07A new Chinese red line over Iran
2007-12-10Annapolis: Why care?
2007-12-22Hamas admits to fatal Israeli bus bombings
2007-12-28The Kurdish Policy Imperative
2009-10-13The Goldstone Report: Killing The Messenger
2009-07-18Palestine's land Islamic endowment can never be dropped:Hamas minister
2009-07-21Report: Israel to evacuate all outposts in a day
2009-07-21Breaking silence on Gaza War
2009-09-12Promises Unfulfilled 100 Days After Obama's Cairo Speech
2009-03-17Solana urges future Israeli gov't to stick to two-state solution
2009-02-21Binyamin Netanyahu warns of Iranian nuclear threat
2009-02-28Unity deal great leap for Palestinians, small step for Gaza truce
2009-03-02Chronology of major talks on Mideast peace
2009-06-28Sarkozy: No Shalit deal unless Israel frees jailed Palestinians
2009-06-16Netanyahu's speech disappoints Palestinians
2009-06-17The narrow strategic thinking of pro-Ahmadinejad Israelis
2009-07-05'This Week' Transcript: EXCLUSIVE: Vice President Joe Biden
2009-07-06Gaza aid boat passengers still in Israeli custody
2009-07-07Aluf Benn / Netanyahu must remember U.S. is stronger than Israel
2009-07-16West Bank economy can grow if Israel eases up: IMF
2009-05-22The Historical Roots of the Anti-Israel Positions of Liberal Protestant Churches -- Interview with Hans Jansen
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 3: State Sponsors of Terrorism
2009-05-11King Abdullah in Mid-East warning
2009-05-07Criminalizing Criticism of Israel -- The End of Free Speech?
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 2. Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2009-06-13Racists for Democracy -- A Fascist Odor of the New Coalition
2009-06-01Questioning the Israeli spin
2009-06-15U.S. hails Israeli PM's foreign policy speech
2009-01-11Gaza: the rights and wrongs
2009-01-11The limits of diplomacy
2009-01-05Orwell, blinding tribalism, selective Terrorism, and Israel/Gaza
2009-01-05Barack Obama’s obsession with Islam
2009-01-18The Necessary Violence of the Murderous National Bully
2009-01-13U.S. Branch of Amnesty Calls on Rice to Drop "Lopsided" Stance
2009-01-15Amnesty International's Anti-Israeli Complaint
2009-01-01Israeli strike kills Hamas political leader
2009-01-03Israel in Gaza: Right but not Smart
2008-12-30‘A Dubai on the Mediterranean’ -- Sara Roy on Gaza’s future
2008-12-30The Tipping Points
2008-12-29Stuart Littlewood
2008-12-20A short path, from Gaza to Somalia
2008-12-22Remarks as Delivered by Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates, Manama, Bahrain
2008-12-22Israeli leaders 'to topple Hamas'
2009-02-11Renewing American Leadership
2009-02-16Bruce Anderson: Israel is trapped, and the chance of peace is ever more remote
2009-02-02Spain investigates claims of Israeli crimes against humanity in Gaza
2009-01-21Iran: Breaking the Nuclear Deadlock -- A Chatham House Report
2009-01-23Reasons for War? -- Livni's Bombs
2009-01-27Did Israel Commit War Crimes in Gaza?
2009-01-28A Performance-Based Roadmap to a Permanent Two-State Solution to the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
2009-01-28On the Wrong Side of History
2009-01-28Israel hits Gaza tunnels as U.S. envoy due
2008-12-07Obama’s Speech in Berlin -- Transcript
2008-12-03Symposium: Iran: The Countdown
2008-11-30EU2020 essay Willing and able? -- EU defence in 2020
2008-11-25Don't Suppress Carter (or the Opportunities for Middle East Peace) -- The Democrats Owe Jimmy Carter an Apology
2008-11-25How Europe Can Help The Middle East Peace Process
2008-11-27Defense establishment paper: Golan for Syria peace, plan for Iran strike
2008-12-06Slow-Motion Genocide in Occupied Palestine
2008-12-14Use of the Veto on United Nations Resolutions by the USA
2008-12-16Slouching toward a Palestinian Holocaust
2008-12-19Ceasefire in Gaza over, violence set to rise
2008-11-09Blueprint for Change -- Obama and Biden’s Plan for America
2008-11-11The Case for Restraint -- Foreign policy after George W. Bush
2008-11-13Conned Again? -- Obama, Rahm-bo and the End of the New American Century
2008-11-13Between Hope and Reality -- An Open Letter to Barack Obama
2008-08-18Here We Go 'Round the Mulberry Bush
2008-08-23Iran Achieves a Four-Front Missile Command, Breakthrough on Nuclear Missile Warheads
2008-08-24Cutting out US role, new Egyptian-Saudi plan proposes inter-Arab force for Gaza
2008-08-17Palestine Should Sue Israel for Genocide before the International Court of Justice
2008-08-17The Palestinian Genocide
2008-08-11Rethinking the National Interest -- American Realism for a New World
2008-09-09Interview Norman Finkelstein: "We ask the ones who were kicked out of their homes, to recognise the legitimacy of the ones who kicked them out."
2008-09-09Is there Hope for the Conflict-Ridden Middle East?
2008-08-31A Real Pro-Israel Policy Helps Palestine, Too
2008-09-02Can The War On Terror Be Won? -- How To Fight The Right War
2008-10-27The Rape of Palestine -- Hope Destroyed, Justice Denied
2008-10-19Vision of Palestine at odds with the world
2008-11-02Book Review: The Case for Palestine: An International Law Perspective
2008-11-07Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2008-09-27Love and Terror
2008-10-08Iran’s Secret Bargain With Bush?
2008-10-11What Went Wrong? Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response
2008-10-11Jihad: The Trail of Political Islam
2008-05-07Image and Reality -- An Interview with Norman Finkelstein
2008-04-24Revamping American Grand Strategy
2008-04-29The Man Between War and Peace
2008-04-22The March to War: Israel Prepares for War against Lebanon and Syria
2008-04-10Eretz Israel HaShlema / Greater Israel
2008-02-29Islamist Bubbles -- Beware the light at the end of the Islamist tunnel
2008-03-03Mead: Bush Administration Gets Improving ‘Grades’ in First Year of Second Term’s Foreign Policy
2008-03-14Aims and Methods of Europe's Muslim Brotherhood
2008-03-16Bush is an idiot, but he was right about Saddam
2008-03-22Muslims, Democracy, and the American Experience
2008-02-23The Two Faces of Saudi Arabia
2008-02-08Assessing the Islamist Threat, Circa 1946
2008-01-18Israeli attacks on Gaza hobble Abbas
2008-01-19A Political-Risk Outlook for 2008
2008-01-28U.S.-Israel Defense Relations on Mend But New American Veto Policy Crimps Israeli Arms Sales
2008-01-29THE WAR ON TERROR: FOUR YEARS ON; Taking Stock Of the Forever War
2008-06-23Gaza Truce Is a Sham, Say Analysts -- Israeli planning shaped by desire to attack Iran
2008-06-16A journey into the heart of the enemy
2008-06-16Not an island -- Europe and the Middle East
2008-06-14A Year Under Hamas Alters Life in Gaza
2008-06-11Palestinians and Israelis Forging Bonds of Peace in Santa Fe
2008-06-04A Peaceful Resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
2008-05-31Israel at Sixty: Asymmetry, Vulnerability, and the Search for Security
2008-05-31The Palestinian Refugee Issue: Rhetoric vs. Reality
2008-05-31Is Israel Bound by International Law to Supply Utilities, Goods, and Services to Gaza?