Argumentations - China must come clean about its poisonous environment

	Posted by: zanshin, 2007-07-05 02:43
Story

	China must come clean about its poisonous environment
	2007-07-03 (Tuesday), FT
	Even in a China that is more capitalist than ever, the instinctive official response to bad news is to suppress it with all the force available to the nominally communist state. Beijing needs to accept that in 2007 this kind of reaction is as futile and dangerous as it was in 2003, when the authorities kept secret the spread of the deadly Sars virus. It is futile because the truth will out and dangerous because secrecy delays the necessary remedial action. So it is with the bowdlerising of a World Bank report on pollution in China. As the Financial Times has reported, the original research found that more than 750,000 Chinese die prematurely each year, mainly from air pollution. The State Environment Protection Agency and the health ministry told the World Bank to cut this from the published report because it was, in the words of an adviser involved in the study, “too sensitive and could cause social unrest”. Chinese officials were probably worried by the detailed breakdown of the worst places to live in China, which showed the most toxic cities clustered in the north-western coal belt. Residents of polluted cities do not need the World Bank to tell them the air is filthy. They breathe the stuff every day. But Chinese officials are right to be nervous. Environmental protests – rural and urban – have proliferated in recent years as Chinese citizens become better educated and more forceful in defence of their rights. In Xiamen, angry residents have stalled plans to build a petrochemical plant seen as a source of lethal pollution. However, the correct response to the sort of grim news contained in the World Bank report is not to suppress the truth but to tackle the underlying problem. Reducing emissions from coal-fired power stations, for example, is neither as expensive nor as difficult as businesses and the provincial governments with which they collude often pretend. Moreover, China can tie the essentially domestic crisis of urban air pollution into solving the international problem of climate change. Spewing out local air pollutants and carbon, the main global warming gas, often go hand in hand. The same holds for modernising plants to avoid either type of emissions. Many foreign companies are eager to fund these clean-up projects in exchange for carbon credits valued at home. In the meantime, these could help China solve its local air pollution problem. All of the above can only happen if Chinese leaders overcome their fear of the facts and start telling the truth. They may find it easier than they think and it would certainly produce better results. Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2007

Comments

No comments yet.

Please login to post your comment.

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Stories, Arguments and Comments are owned by the Poster.
The Rest copyright © 2007 Argumentations.com. All rights reserved. Argumentations.com provides material for research or educational purposes only. We do not warrant the correctness of its contents. The risk from using it lies entirely with the user. While using this site, you agree to have read and accepted our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Argumentations.com is far from perfect so if you have any critiques, questions, comments or problems about this site please tell us. Click here to send your feedback. And if you like Argumentations.com please link to this site. It will really help a lot.

Related statements

No results

View other suggested stories

Date added
2006-09-29	China -- PART 2: Tequila trap beckons China
2007-08-25	As China Roars, Pollution Reaches Deadly Extremes
2008-04-07	Famine, food and fertilizer
2008-11-14	Towards a Grand Strategy for an Uncertain World -- Renewing Transatlantic Partnership
2009-01-16	The Joint Operating Environment (JOE)
2009-05-08	A Leadership Review of the Barack Obama Administration
2008-11-09	Blueprint for Change -- Obama and Biden’s Plan for America
2008-10-24	The World Around Russia: 2017 -- An Outlook for the Midterm Future
2008-11-23	21st Century Strategies For Sustainability
2008-11-24	Why Obama Missed Bretton Woods II
2008-11-24	Global Trends 2025: A Transformed World -- Executive Summary
2008-12-27	Barack Obama: The Naked Emperor
2008-04-12	Are We Approaching a Global Food Crisis?
2008-04-16	A Review of the Seminar ‘the Security of Energy Supplies: the Role of NATO and Other International Organisations’
2008-05-17	The world health report 2007 : a safer future : global public health security in the 21st century.
2008-06-10	Impeach George W. Bush Resolution
2008-07-20	Living on the Ice Shelf -- Humanity's Meltdown
2007-10-22	How to aid destruction
2007-12-20	Press Conference by the President
2008-01-02	Dust, waste and dirty water: the deadly price of China's miracle
2008-01-02	China wakes up to the dangers of pollution
2007-07-03	750,000 a year killed by Chinese pollution
2007-07-05	750,000 a year killed by Chinese pollution
2007-07-04	Rising to a New Generation of Global Challenges
2007-07-31	The American Empire is Failing – A Good Thing for America and the World -- An Interview with Terry Paupp
2007-06-12	Building a New Consensus on China
2006-09-30	A Short History of Neo-liberalism - Twenty Years of Elite Economics and Emerging Opportunities for Structural Change
2006-10-03	Transcript of a Press Conference on the World Economic Outlook Report
2006-10-09	The Anglo-American War of Terror: An Overview
2006-08-21	Ask the experts: Urban planet
2006-08-30	How Black Is Coal?
2007-01-24	President Bush’s State of the Union Address
2007-01-01	Only renewed multilateralism can save America
2006-12-03	The Way Out of War - A blueprint for leaving Iraq now
2006-11-14	Grand Strategy as Order Building
2007-01-07	New Ripples And Responses To China’s Water Woes
2007-03-19	A New Sorrow for Afghanistan: AIDS Joins List
2007-03-20	Nowadays, Angola Is Oil’s Topic A
2006-09-09	Cost of water shortage: civil unrest, mass migration and economic collapse
2006-08-25	The End Of The Oil Era Looms
2006-04-20	The Next Iraqi War? Sectarianism and Civil Conflict
2006-05-01	Scholars Predict 50 Million “Environmental Refugees” by 2010
2006-10-07	Death of city-states
2006-09-30	The World Bank and International Monetary Fund
2007-06-11	Should We Globalize Labor Too?
2007-06-06	Contours Of The Putin Era
2007-06-13	Resource Wars - Can We Survive Them?
2007-06-13	Press Conference by the President
2007-06-22	New Five-Year Plan for Vietnam
2007-05-15	The New Demographic Balance in Europe and its Consequences
2007-05-22	We're Number One! America Leads the World in War Profits
2007-06-06	Nato’s Islamists
2007-04-03	Mbeki seeks ways to limit chaos to the north and within
2007-04-15	Interview with Simeon Djankov, World Bank analyst
2007-04-17	Commission Adopts Resolutions On Combating Defamation Of Religions; Right To Development
2007-04-25	Gravy Train: Feeding The Pentagon By Feeding Somalia
2007-05-02	Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 5 -- Terrorist Safe Havens (7120 Report)
2007-05-02	Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 6 -- Terrorist Organizations
2007-05-02	Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2007-05-10	EU urged to resist China 'bullying'
2007-05-10	Bystanders to Genocide
2007-07-14	A Convenient Untruth
2007-07-12	House Armed Services Committee Global Security Assessment Statement For The Record
2007-07-09	UN issues desertification warning
2007-07-06	Climate Report Seen Setting Out Scary Scenarios
2007-07-04	Cost of Pollution in China: Economic Estimates of Physical Damages
2007-06-18	Israel-Lebanon conflict - timeline of events
2007-06-19	GENERAL PETER PACE, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, National Press Club Luncheon, Washington D.C.
2007-06-19	CNN LATE EDITION WITH WOLF BLITZER
2007-08-15	President Delivers State of the Union Address
2007-09-09	That empty-nest feeling
2007-09-12	2 Years After Narrow Victory, Germany’s Merkel Cruises on Her Popularity
2007-08-05	The End of Cowboy Diplomacy
2007-08-07	In Dusty Archives, a Theory of Affluence
2007-08-08	The Global War on Terrorism -- The First 100 Days
2007-08-18	Water as a Right and Key to Social Stability
2007-08-23	Infectious diseases spreading faster than ever: U.N.
2008-01-02	Child trafficking: Protecting children in a society on the move
2007-12-29	A World of Problems . . .
2007-12-20	The Nobel Lecture given by The Nobel Peace Prize Laureate 2007, Al Gore
2007-12-22	Bush/Gore Second Presidential Debate October 11
2007-12-22	Clinton on Foreign Policy at University of Nebraska
2007-12-12	Action will speak louder than words
2007-12-13	Bilderberg 2007 - Towards a One World Empire?
2008-01-11	The $1.4 Trillion Question
2008-01-19	Britain, China boost links on tackling climate change
2008-01-19	A Political-Risk Outlook for 2008
2008-01-21	More Instruments and Broader Goals: Moving Toward the Post-Washington Consensus
2008-01-14	Belgo-British Conference 2005 -- 2020 – a new horizon for Europe
2008-02-01	Global Banking: The Bank for International Settlements
2008-02-04	Globalization: Stiglitz's Case
2008-02-04	Hydrogen Economy Enablers
2007-10-03	Why the United States Invaded Iraq and is Now Thinking About Invading Iran
2007-10-05	Power Plays: Fears Over Looming Energy Crisis In Uk
2007-10-09	Korean Peace Process Leaps Forward
2007-09-09	It's the Demography, Stupid
2007-09-25	China in Three Colors
2007-09-24	Betrayed -- The Iraqis who trusted America the most
2007-09-25	Gas Negotiations Continue In Russia
2007-10-29	Balancing Exploration & Production Technology Needs
2007-10-30	Lee Kuan Yew
2007-11-01	The Breaking Point
2007-11-04	The Coming Economic Collapse by Dr Stephen Leeb -- Book Review
2007-11-07	The "Limits to Growth" Revisited
2007-11-10	The rising tide: assessing the risks of climate change and human settlements in low elevation coastal zones
2007-11-26	Water Scarcity Here Now: Part 23--Next Added 100 Million Americans
2007-11-28	Does the Future Belong to China?
2008-07-16	What’s Your Consumption Factor?
2008-08-01	Al Gore: A Generational Challenge to Repower America
2008-06-27	President Delivers "State of the Union"
2008-08-11	Rethinking the National Interest -- American Realism for a New World
2008-08-01	The Democrats & National Security
2008-08-30	Transcript: Al Gore's speech at Invesco Field
2008-09-18	US Genocide in Iraq
2008-09-13	The Emerging Water Wars
2008-04-29	The Pentagon's New Map
2008-05-12	National Water Program Strategy: Response To Climate Change
2008-05-15	Yankees Head Home
2008-05-16	How to manufacture a global food crisis: lessons from the World Bank, IMF, and WTO
2008-05-29	Child survival in Africa – seven signs of hope
2008-06-01	Skyrocketing Oil Prices Threaten Prosperity
2008-06-04	A Peaceful Resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
2008-04-01	Miracle in the desert
2008-04-01	The Big Guns Behind the Global War Machine -- The WTO and the Global War System
2008-03-29	Why the US is collapsing
2008-03-19	The new liberal imperialism
2008-03-23	Future Human Evolution -- Eugenics in the Twenty-First Century
2008-03-24	Global Migration Patterns and Job Creation
2008-03-24	Globalization And The Development Of Underdevelopment Of The Third World
2008-03-26	President Discusses Second Term Accomplishments and Priorities
2008-12-14	Use of the Veto on United Nations Resolutions by the USA
2008-12-15	Suddenly vulnerable
2008-12-20	Davos 07: the sound of the city
2008-12-29	The World Economic Crisis: A Marxist Analysis
2008-12-30	Watching the Rouble Go Down -- Diary

Sign In to:

Story

China must come clean about its poisonous environment

Comments

Tags

Related statements

View other suggested stories