Posted by: zanshin, 2007-11-07 12:04

Story

Seeing the Bigger Picture in Iraq
Barin Kayaoglu, 2007-04-16 (Monday), Turkish Weekly
When embarking on a course of action, every prudent political actor should first define legitimate and acceptable success. Every move should begin by having a realistic objective. Decision-makers ought to consider whether success is achievable with the tools at hand. Next, planners need to evaluate whether the strategy is designed to realize the objective. If the plan involves military action, how would the army on the field adapt to changing conditions (the fog of war effect)? It is also important for civilian rulers and military strategists to be in tune with each other. More importantly, can society be persuaded to support military action? Similarly, are other countries supportive of military action; is there a chance to build a coalition? Coming full circle, policy-makers need to reflect on how they will bring military operations to an end.

Policy-makers in Ankara are pondering these issues when thinking about a possible operation in Northern Iraq. Given the gravity of the situation and the factors at hand, a military operation in Northern Iraq can get Turkey bogged down in the wrong war, at the wrong place, at the wrong time.

Although Turkey voices concern over the status of Kirkuk and the coming referendum, its only concern is the attacks staged by the terrorist organization PKK from Northern Iraq. Anger toward Iraqi Kurds, who are perceived to be harboring the PKK, is building with every funeral procession for a fallen Turkish soldier.

The ultimate paradox of the Kurdish regional government and the central government in Baghdad is that a terrorist group is launching attacks from their territory against another sovereign state. A good deal of the time, we hear that the reason why the regional and central governments in Iraq cannot move against the PKK is that they could not exert complete control over PKK’s base in Mt. Kandil. Iraqis’ claim to sovereignty is challenged not by Turkey, but by a terrorist group which spreads nothing but chaos into Southeastern Turkey and Northern Iraq.

Looking at the bigger picture, the cautious observer is tempted to warn decision-makers in Ankara, Erbil, and Baghdad about the consequences of a Turkish operation into Northern Iraq. In the 1990s, Turkey conducted two massive operations and nearly a dozen smaller ones into Northern Iraq. It was not until a great opportunity presented itself when PKK’s Stalin-wannabe leader Abdullah Öcalan was captured in 1999 that Turkey was able to remarkably halt the terrorist group.

More importantly, during the operations in the 1990s, Turkey was supported by the peshmerga units of Messrs. Jalal Talabani and Masoud Barzani. Although this cooperation had a mixed record of succes then, Iraqis – Kurdish and Arab – are overtly warning Turkey that its troops are not welcome today.

The Turkish side should be receptive to the fact that Iraq is in a very bad situation right now. We are essentially talking about a government that cannot guarantee the physical safety of its parliament building. Compare that to the situation in Ankara, where only two honor guards protect the spacious park in front of the Turkish Grand National Assembly. One can see that Iraq has more existential problems than Turkey. At the moment, by helping the economic reconstruction of Iraq, Turkey presents itself as a small but respectful solution to Iraq’s problems. But if Turkey decides to conduct a military operation into Iraq, it will choose to become part of the problem.

The Iraqi side, however, is not without its responsibilities. Iraqi administrators in Erbil and Baghdad ought to see that Turkish people are becoming fed up with violence. The PKK is poisoning Turkey’s relations with Iraq in general and the Iraqi Kurds in particular. Although a full-scale operation by peshmerga forces and the Iraqi army is not conceivable at this stage, honest gestures such as denying the PKK financial and logistical opportunities in Northern Iraq can convince Turkish leaders that their Kurdish counterparts mean business. That can ease tensions significantly. A failure to do that can turn events for the worst.

On another note, leaders on both sides need to refrain from making extravagant remarks to the press. “Oh God! That men should put an enemy in their mouths to steal away their brains” warns William Shakespeare in Othello. In an age where sensational news is the only thing that sells, responsible officials have to be more careful with what they say. An accumulation of unwise could lead to very nasty outcomes (which would mean more business for the press). There is not a single sensible reason why Turks and Iraqis should fight each other and a lot of good ones why they should not.

Everyone who is concerned about the prospects of more bloodshed in Iraq should remember the following: Last June, retired U.S. Army Lt. Col. Ralph Peters advocated the redrawing of borders in the Middle East with blood. In his article “Blood Borders,” Mr. Peters argued that the Middle East would look much better if new borders would be drawn by blood (his article was subtitled “How a Better Middle East Would Look”).[i]

Those craving for a good fight should bear in mind that whatever new borders or bold strokes they may want to achieve, all of that is going to happen at the expense of their own blood.


Barin Kayaoglu is a Ph.D. student in history at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, Virginia and a regular contributor to the Journal of Turkish Weekly.


[i] Ralph Peters, “Blood Borders: How a Better Middle East Would Look,” Armed Forces Journal, June 2006; available from http://www.armedforcesjournal.com/2006/06/1833899. Also see my response to Mr. Peters; Barin Kayaoglu, “Drawing Borders with Other People’s Blood: A Brief Comment on Ralph Peters’s ‘Blood Borders,’” 19 July 2006; available from http://www.turkishweekly.net/comments.php?id=2202.

Comments


No comments yet.

Please login to post your comment.












All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Stories, Arguments and Comments are owned by the Poster.
The Rest copyright © 2007 Argumentations.com. All rights reserved. Argumentations.com provides material for research or educational purposes only. We do not warrant the correctness of its contents. The risk from using it lies entirely with the user. While using this site, you agree to have read and accepted our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Argumentations.com is far from perfect so if you have any critiques, questions, comments or problems about this site please tell us. Click here to send your feedback. And if you like Argumentations.com please link to this site. It will really help a lot.
   

Tags

Arab,   Greece,   Iraq,   Kenya,   Kurdistan,   Kurds,   military,   Open-Ended Issues,   PKK,   Ralph Peters,   Turkey,  

Related statements

View other suggested stories

Date added 
2007-03-18Between Europe And The Middle East: The Transformation Of Turkish Policy
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 6 -- Terrorist Organizations
2007-06-18A PACKAGE DEAL FOR THE MIDDLE EAST
2007-07-19Kurdish mountain army awaiting the next invasion of Iraq
2007-12-28The Kurdish Policy Imperative
2008-01-11After Iraq
2008-11-07Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 --
2007-12-26Turkish planes hit Iraqi Kurdish villages
2007-12-16'US backed' Turkish raids on Iraq
2007-12-18Turkey's EU Membership's Possible Impacts on the Middle East
2007-08-23Why Exiting Iraq Wont Be Easy
2007-09-08Does independence beckon?
2007-11-01PKK Circumverts Ban in Germany
2007-11-07Blood borders -- How a better Middle East would look
2007-11-07Drawing Borders with Other People’s Blood: A Brief Comment on Ralph Peters’s 'Blood Borders'
2007-11-12NATO Expands into Arab South
2007-11-22The United States’ new backyard
2007-07-19Turkey Bombards Northern Iraq, Iraq Says
2007-07-19Talk of invasion
2007-06-16Turkish Military Leaders Pushing For Invasion of Northern Iraq
2006-04-20The Next Iraqi War? Sectarianism and Civil Conflict
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 2. Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2008-10-24The World Around Russia: 2017 -- An Outlook for the Midterm Future
2009-01-21Iran: Breaking the Nuclear Deadlock -- A Chatham House Report
2008-02-13Recent tension between Greece and Turkey -- FACTBOX
2008-06-16Not an island -- Europe and the Middle East
2006-09-07New Targets, Old Conflicts
2007-03-10The Analysis: On the ‘Polarization’ of Iraqis and Their ‘Ready Recourse to Violence’
2006-12-06Transcript - The Nomination Hearing for Robert M. Gates
2006-12-30Obituary - Saddam Hussein
2007-06-08Islam and Liberal Democracy: A Historical Overview
2007-07-19Expert urges US to pressure Barzani on PKK
2007-07-19OEI - Turkey will invade Iraq
2007-07-12House Armed Services Committee Global Security Assessment Statement For The Record
2007-07-12Prospects for Iraq’s Stability: A Challenging Road Ahead
2007-08-03Making an Iraq of Kurdistan
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 5 -- Terrorist Safe Havens (7120 Report)
2007-04-17Commission Adopts Resolutions On Combating Defamation Of Religions; Right To Development
2007-05-05WHY IRAN WILL HAVE THE BOMB
2007-05-10Wartime Friendships
2007-05-11Turkey Eyes the Shia Crescent
2007-05-11Prospects for Iraq’s Stability: A Challenging Road Ahead
2007-05-22Turkey at the boiling point
2007-06-06Nato’s Islamists
2007-11-13The Deadly Embrace
2007-11-13Turkish gunships attack villages inside Iraq
2007-11-21Wars to Watch Out For
2007-12-01Military authorized for cross-border offensive, PM says
2007-12-03Turkey Says It Attacked Kurdish Fighters in Iraq
2007-11-11Inevitable Iran-Turkey-Syria-Russia Alliance
2007-11-06Bush steps up US aid to Turkey against Kurdish rebels
2007-11-06Secretary Rice in Ankara: Mission Impossible?
2007-11-01Where are we at in the crisis?
2007-10-30Turkey Campaigns To Oust Kurd Fighters
2007-11-05Bush to hold talks with Turkish leader on Iraqi Kurds
2007-09-28Turkey, Iraq sign deal to combat Kurdish rebels
2007-10-03The Iraqi Balfour Declaration?
2007-10-08Turkey weighs response over attack
2007-10-12Turkey ready to face world criticism over Iraq
2007-10-11Turkey May Request Incursion Into Iraq
2007-10-15US tries to halt Turkey attack
2007-10-16Iraq incursion not inevitable - Erdogan
2007-10-22A fight on many fronts
2007-10-22Attack spurs anger, plans
2007-10-23Iraq Must Act `Immediately' Against Kurdish Rebels, Rice Says
2007-10-28Turkish army clashes with Kurdish rebels, 15 reported killed
2007-10-22Iraqi Kurds march for peace as raids by Turkey loom
2007-10-29Turkish army encircles 100 Kurdish rebels
2007-08-27Turkey to take action to protect interests in Iraq, US report says
2007-09-18Political Tensions Hit Turkish Economic Ties With Northern Iraq
2007-08-06Turkey to Warn Iraq on Rebel Sanctuaries
2007-08-07Military does not favor action with US to behead PKK
2007-08-07Bush's Turkish Gamble
2007-08-09No Iraq-Turkey pact on separatists
2007-08-09Turkey wins Iraq pledge on PKK, wants action
2007-08-09Al-Maliki Declines Turkish Terror Treaty
2007-12-18Turkish soldiers cross into Iraq
2007-12-18Babacan responds to EU tensions and Palestine
2007-12-08Our last occupation -- Gas, chemicals, bombs: Britain has used them all before in Iraq
2007-12-12EU Leads Calls for Restraint as Turkey Launches Air Strikes
2007-12-25Turkey Says Its Raids in Iraq Killed 150 Rebels
2008-01-02Turkish accession to the European union: challenges and opportunities
2008-01-03Car bomb kills five in Turkey's main Kurdish city
2008-06-10Impeach George W. Bush Resolution
2008-02-25Ethnonationalism
2008-04-18Choosing War: The Decision to Invade Iraq and Its Aftermath
2008-10-28Turkey extends mandate for striking PKK in N Iraq
2008-10-29Military: Turkey launches airstrike on PKK targets in Iraq
2008-10-16Turkish delegation on Iraqi mission against PKK
2008-08-25The Worldwide Threat 2004: Challenges in a Changing Global Context
2008-10-04Fifteen Turkish soldiers killed in clashes with PKK
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 2. Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2009-05-22The Revenge of Geography
2009-07-19Turkey and Russia on the Rise
2007-12-19British hand security in Basra to Iraqi forces
2007-12-16Turkish planes bomb northern Iraq in hunt for PKK
2007-12-12Top commanders lash out at DTP, European Union
2007-12-12Cut financial resources to cripple PKK, says expert
2007-12-12General accuses allies of providing safe haven to PKK
2007-12-15Why We Should Oppose an Independent Kosovo
2008-01-04US-Iraq Challenges in 2008
2008-01-05Syria wants bigger share from Euphrates
2008-01-05Real axis of evil
2007-08-09KGI - Kurdistan - Thursday, 2007-08-09
2007-08-08The Global War on Terrorism -- The First 100 Days
2007-08-07Maliki in Turkey for Cooperation on Terrorism
2007-08-07Framing Kurdistan
2007-08-16Turkey working to jumpstart peace talks between Israel, Syria
2007-08-23Prospects for Iraq’s Stability: Some Security Progress but Political Reconciliation Elusive
2007-08-25Iraqi Factions’ Self-Interest Blocks Political Progress -- News Analysis
2007-08-2512 killed in Kurdish-Turkish clash
2007-08-26Iraqi VP delivers Sunni ultimatum
2007-08-26Iraq's leaders agree on key benchmarks
2007-08-18Remote northeast Iraq hit by Iran shells: officials
2007-08-20America's pipedream: A position of over isolation
2007-08-21Leaflets said to warn of Iran move into north Iraq
2007-09-21US embarrasses the Kurds once again
2007-09-21Burns visit deepens the gap between two allies
2007-09-22Feds Probe Blackwater Over Alleged Weapons Smuggling
2007-09-08Justice, up to a point
2007-09-08The other Jerusalem
2007-09-07Understanding the U.S.-Israel Alliance: An Israeli Response to the Walt-Mearsheimer Claim
2007-09-08Breaking Up
2007-09-09Guns and votes
2007-10-22Turkey bombards northern Iraq after ambush
2007-10-22Diplomacy staves off Turkish incursion
2007-10-23Torture in the Name of Freedom
2007-10-29Crude Oil Rises to Record on Turkey-Iraq Tensions, Nigeria
2007-10-21Report: 9 Turkish Soldiers Killed
2007-10-17Turkey to vote on Iraq incursion, Baghdad pleads for time
2007-10-17Solana warns Turkey against military incursion in Iraq
2007-10-07100,000 U.S. troops could leave soon: Iraq president
2007-11-01EU slams 'military meddling'
2007-11-02Turkey says time for action against Kurd rebels
2007-11-08Assessing the surge
2007-11-11The Next Act -- Is a damaged Administration less likely to attack Iran, or more?
2007-11-11The Seven Deadly Sins of Failure in Iraq: A Retrospective Analysis of the Reconstruction
2007-11-11Kurdish Party DTP Approves Declaration For Autonomy
2007-11-11Remember Iraq
2007-11-11In the Wake of War: Geo-strategy, Terrorism, Oil Markets, and Domestic Politics
2007-11-29In Iraq, Water and Oil Do Mix -- Water Woes
2007-11-16The Threat of Maritime Terrorism to Israel
2007-05-22Statements made by Democratic leaders about Saddam Hussein's acquisition or possession of WMD
2007-05-11Waning Chances for Stability -- Least Bad Options in a Failed, War-Torn State
2007-05-03Timeline: Al-Qaeda
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2007-04-02From the Wonderful Folks Who Brought You Iraq
2007-04-04The Next World Order
2007-04-10How to Get Out of Iraq
2007-04-15Thinking Aloud on Turkey's EU Bid
2007-04-15Opening Statement On Behalf Of The Jury Of Conscience Of The World Tribunal Of Iraq
2007-07-31CNN Late Edition with Wolf Blitzer
2007-07-22Iran's Renewed Threats to Take Over the Arab Gulf States
2007-07-23PKK should do ‘whatever it takes’ to provoke Turkey to invade Northern Iraq
2007-07-24Withdrawal is not an option
2007-07-13Initial Benchmark Assessment Report
2007-07-13CFR: What are Iraq's Benchmarks?
2007-07-10U.S. Envoy Offers Grim Prediction on Iraq Pullout
2007-07-17Shiite Cleric’s Bloc Returns to Parliament
2007-07-13The New York Times Surrenders -- A monument to defeatism on the editorial page
2007-06-08The Turks ponder a cross-border incursion into northern Iraq
2007-06-13Gov't's final word on incursion: NO
2007-06-17More Smoke on the Horizon in the Middle East War Theater
2007-06-19CNN LATE EDITION WITH WOLF BLITZER
2007-06-19A New Offensive in Diyala
2007-06-22Only Connect -- A Roundtable on the Iraq Study Group Report
2007-06-24"Chemical Ali" sentenced to hang
2007-06-28A deadly blow for Iraqi reconciliation
2007-07-02Zionist Plan for the Middle East
2007-01-08Changing Strategies, Changing Allies - Bush Capitulates To Reality In The Middle East
2006-12-09Iraqis Near Deal on Distribution of Oil Revenues by Population
2007-01-09Despite their shoddy track record on Iraq analysis, O'Reilly trusts only "my military analysts
2007-03-14Sweden: Restrictive Immigration Policy and Multiculturalism
2007-03-01The “White” al-Qaeda and the Future of Europe
2007-03-18Kemal Kirisci: A multi-cultural society: an interview with Kemal Kirisci
2007-03-18Turkey and the US: The tail wagging the dog
2007-03-18The world according to Baker
2006-05-01How to Win in Iraq
2006-10-27What Went Wrong in Iraq
2009-07-15U.S. hawks want terrorists to take down Iran govt.
2009-06-01Questioning the Israeli spin
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 4: The Global Challenge of WMD Terrorism
2009-05-18Turkey hits Kurdish bases in Iraq
2008-10-02U.S. Not Winning War on Terror -- Special Report
2008-09-26Copenhagen Consensus 2008 Challenge Paper Terrorism
2008-09-12Iran Must Get Ready to Repel a Nuclear Attack
2008-09-13TERRORISM, HUMAN RIGHTS, SOCIAL JUSTICE, FREEDOM AND DEMOCRACY: SOME CONSIDERATIONS FOR THE LEGAL AND JUSTICE PROFESSIONALS OF THE ‘COALITION OF THE WILLING’
2008-09-18US Genocide in Iraq
2008-08-25The changes in the fight against illegal immigration in the Euro-Mediterranean area and in Euro-Mediterranean relations
2008-10-11What Went Wrong? Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response
2008-11-07Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Middle East and North Africa Overview
2008-11-14Towards a Grand Strategy for an Uncertain World -- Renewing Transatlantic Partnership
2008-11-17Clinton Is The WorId's Leading Active War Criminal
2008-11-30EU2020 essay Willing and able? -- EU defence in 2020
2008-04-22The March to War: Israel Prepares for War against Lebanon and Syria
2008-04-10Eretz Israel HaShlema / Greater Israel
2008-02-26Fitzgerald: Islam for Infidels, Part Two
2008-03-04The Last Days of Europe
2008-03-25Globalisation & War -- International congress of IPPNW
2008-02-01Iraq: The Way Out -- Transcript
2008-02-02Kurds’ Power Wanes as Arab Anger Rises
2008-01-19Rice's top adviser conducts consultations in Ankara on Iraq
2008-01-19A Political-Risk Outlook for 2008
2008-01-25Al Qaeda goes north: Police chief killed in Mosul
2008-06-08The Operator: The Double Life of a Military Strategist
2008-06-27Daughter of the Enlightenment
2008-06-30Preparing the Battlefield
2008-05-17The world health report 2007 : a safer future : global public health security in the 21st century.
2008-07-09Who's Planning Our Next War?
2008-07-28The Geopolitics of Iran: Holding the Center of a Mountain Fortress
2006-10-26Blaming the lobby
2006-09-12The Nation That Fell to Earth
2006-09-24Full text of Bashar Assad's interview with Kuwait daily 'Al-Anbaa'
2006-09-29Afghanistan: Why NATO cannot win
2006-11-06Iraqi Shiites, Kurds Rejoice on Verdict; Sunnis Mourn (Update3)
2006-11-07TURKEY AND THE AZERBAIJANI OIL CONTROVERSIES: LOOKING FOR A LIGHT AT THE END OF THE PIPELINE
2006-11-07MAGHREB REGIME SCENARIOS
2006-11-09Tolerable or Awful: The Roads Left in Iraq
2006-05-01U.S. Is Seeking Better Balance In Iraqi Police
2006-05-01Voices Baffled, Brash and Irate in Guantánamo
2006-05-01Shiites Try to Block Start of Parliament on Sunday
2006-05-01U.S. Pushes for Broad Coalition as Iraqi Parliament Prepares to Open
2006-05-01Dash to Baghdad Left Top U.S. Generals Divided
2006-05-01Accusations About General May Expand Rift in Turkey
2006-05-01Iraqi Sunni Bloc to Rejoin Talks on Government
2006-05-01Syria -- He doesn't know where to go
2006-05-01Shiites Get Demand: Drop Jaafari From Race
2006-05-01Women, Islam, and the New Iraq
2006-09-11Proposal for Autonomous States in Iraq Creates Tension
2006-09-12New Glory
2006-08-24On the Verge of Collapse
2007-03-21Chris Hedges: The Christian Right’s War on America
2007-03-21Text of the Rockford College graduation speech by Chris Hedges
2007-03-14Timeline of events in the Cold War
2007-03-14Review of Current Trends in U.S. Foreign Policy
2007-03-22The hidden wives of Turkey
2007-03-27Our World: Condi's embrace of jihadist 'peace'
2007-03-03The Wars of Sudan
2007-03-01President Bush Discusses Progress in Afghanistan, Global War on Terror
2007-03-05Timeline: al-Qaida
2007-03-09GLIMMER OF HOPE FOR BAGHDAD
2007-01-18Annotate This: Escalation in Iraq
2007-01-23Crusading in the Arc of Instability - George Bush's Crusading Scorecard (2001-2007)
2007-02-19Hating America
2006-12-12Iraqis Consider Ways to Reduce Power of Cleric
2006-12-03Baghdad Year Zero - Pillaging Iraq in pursuit of a neocon utopia
2006-12-30Saddam’s Rise and Fall
2007-07-04Rising to a New Generation of Global Challenges
2007-07-05The Secret Way to War
2007-06-25Somalia: The Other (Hidden) War for Oil
2007-06-22Symposium: Strategies of Death
2007-06-22Rice Talks With Journal's Editorial Board
2007-06-22Al Qaeda Strikes Back
2007-06-18Israel-Lebanon conflict - timeline of events
2007-06-19Vanishing Christians of the Mideast -- The Silent Exodus
2007-06-17Iran's secret plan for summer offensive to force US out of Iraq
2007-06-17General Tommy Franks -- An exclusive interview with America's top general in the war on terrorism
2007-06-15Gates meets top U.S. military commanders in Iraq
2007-06-08Race and Slavery in the Middle East
2007-06-08Political Islam
2007-06-07How Permanent Are Those Bases?
2007-07-17Benchmark Boogie: A Guide to the Struggle Over Iraq's Oil
2007-07-17Plan, don't panic
2007-07-09How to Win in Iraq—and How to Lose
2007-07-08The Road Home - Editorial
2007-07-09Interview transcript: David Miliband
2007-07-13Iraq fears Turkey troop build-up
2007-07-17Exit Strategies
2007-07-26President Bush Discusses War on Terror in South Carolina
2007-07-27Back to the Future? -- The Mideast landscape
2007-07-27Warning: West could lose Turkey
2007-07-27To Check Syria, U.S. Explores Bond With Muslim Brothers