Posted by: zanshin, 2008-09-09 12:38

Story

Burying Girls Alive to Save Family Honor

Shaheen Buneri, 2008-09-07 (Sunday), Media Line
[Peshawar] Civil organizations and women’s rights groups are marching in the main streets of all major cities of Pakistan to try to force the government to put an end to honor killings and to take immediate and strenuous action against the perpetrators.

Reports of the live burial of five women, including three girls, to protect family honor in South Western Baluchistan Province of Pakistan, has deeply shocked the nation.

The girls, who were apparently planning to marry men of their choice, were allegedly killed by their relatives to uphold family honor and to punish them for their “illicit” behavior.

Immediately after the gruesome incident was reported in the local media, civil rights groups started protest demonstrations in front of the parliament building in the country’s capital Islamabad.

Pro-establishment senator Sardar Israrullah Zehri, from Baluchistan province, defended the killings as “centuries-old tribal custom,” and asked senators to refrain from “politicizing the issue.”

According to information collected by the Hong Kong-based Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC), the five women – Fatima, wife of Umeed Ali Umrani, Jannat Bibi, wife of Qaisar Khan, Fauzia, daughter of Ata Mohammad Umrani, and two other girls, aged 16 and 18 – were buried alive in a remote village.

Media reports say the gory incident occurred on July 13, when it is alleged that Abdul Sattar Umrani, the younger brother of Mir Sadiq Umrani, a provincial minister in the Baluchistan cabinet and a senior leader of the ruling Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), along with a band of armed men, forced the five women into their vehicle bearing the number plates of the Baluchistan government, and transported them to a desert in the remote area of Nau Abadi, in the vicinity of Baba Kot.

The AHRC states that Sattar Umrani and his six accomplices took the three girls out of the jeep and tortured them before opening fire on them. The girls were seriously wounded but were still alive. Umrani and his accomplices hurled them into a wide ditch and covered them with mud and stones. When the two older women protested over the burial of girls while they were still alive, the enraged perpetrators also killed them.

The matter was hushed up for six weeks by the local authorities due to the strong political influence of the brother of the alleged murderer who supervised the killing.

On August 29 the incident was brought to the notice of the upper chamber of the Pakistani parliament by a female senator, Yasmin Shah.

Defending the brutal action, Senator Zehri remarked, “These are centuries-old traditions and I will continue to defend them."

However, Senator Sanaullah Baloch, a nationalist leader from the province where the act occurred, said that burying girls alive had never been a custom in the Baloch society.

Wazhma Frogh, a women’s rights activist, observed that the live burials of the women in Baluchistan was reminiscent of the pre-Islamic era in Arab countries, when people would bury their daughters alive to save family honor.

“It has never been embedded in our culture and social traditions,” she maintained.

The delay in action against those responsible, who enjoys perks and privileges as feudal lords in the area, has called into question the credibility of erstwhile pro-women policies of the ruling Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) of slain premier Benazir Bhutto, who always advocated civil and political liberties for women.

Official sources in the country‘s capital Islamabad say that the PPP-led government had been reluctant to take action against the perpetrators as it feared it might lose the votes of a number of legislators sympathetic to Sadiq Umrani, who is also deputy parliamentary leader of the party in Baluchistan Assembly, in the just-held September 6 presidential elections.

Rahman Malik, adviser to the Pakistan Interior Ministry, announced last Monday in the Senate that three suspects in the honor killings of three young girls in Nasirabad district of Baluchistan had been arrested.


Malik added that, “a complete report will be presented before the House within three days.”


However, in its editorial on September 3, the Pakistan Daily News International wrote: “But, sadly, even as the Senate passed a unanimous resolution condemning the incident and demanding punishment for its perpetrators, an attempt at a cover-up is on. The government presented an extremely dubious report before the Senate, stating three women and not five had been killed, that the incident involved a property dispute and was not a case of 'honor' killing and that the women had been killed before being buried.”

The paper claimed Tariq Khosa, who was assigned to probe the gory incident, had been quietly prevented from visiting the scene of the crime and made to sit in Islamabad, with a limited mandate to only monitor investigations.

Meanwhile, Baluchistan minister Sadiq Umrani, while addressing a press conference, said that only two women, and not five, had been killed.

“My family has nothing to do with the incident and my rivals have launched a smear against me,” he added.

Last Monday the Baluchistan High Court ordered the police and the Human Rights Commission to submit their reports relating to the murders by September 22.

In 2005 the government of then president Pervez Musharraf passed a law banning honor killing, with a penalty of death for those who violate it. But in many cases the law has been poorly enforced and perpetrators of violence against women have been freed due to political influence and their connections with the local administration.

In Pakistan’s rural areas, where 70 percent of the country’s population lives, tribal councils known as jirgas or penchayats decide on issues of honor. While these tribal councils have no legal standing in the country’s constitution, a tribal council can seal the fate of a woman if she rebels against the tribal traditions by having her stoned in public or allowing her to be killed by her own relatives. She has no representation in the council and has no right to protest.

“Despite the fact that the high courts and the Supreme Court have declared such jirgas illegal and their judgments invalid, in both cases no police or judicial action has been taken against the jirga members or the perpetrators,” the Women’s Action Forum said in a press statement.

The action forum also condemned a recent jirga judgment because of which three minor girls – Tasleema (five), Aneela (three) and Shaneela (two) – from Sindh were still in hiding with their family following the local jirga’s decision to hand them over as compensation in an alleged “honor” case.

Similarly, another jirga held in June on the Balochistan-Sindh border issued a verdict that 15 minor girls (one only four days old) were allowed to be given away as compensation to end a long-standing dispute between two rival tribes.

According to the Aurat Foundation, a women’s rights NGO working in Pakistan, at least 90 women were murdered in honor killings in the first three months of 2008. Moreover, it claims there are thousands of such cases that have not been referred to the police or exposed by the media due to medieval tribal traditions and the conservative nature of the society.

Copyright © 2008 The Media Line

Comments


No comments yet.

Please login to post your comment.













All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners.
Stories, Arguments and Comments are owned by the Poster.
The Rest copyright © 2007 Argumentations.com. All rights reserved. Argumentations.com provides material for research or educational purposes only. We do not warrant the correctness of its contents. The risk from using it lies entirely with the user. While using this site, you agree to have read and accepted our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Argumentations.com is far from perfect so if you have any critiques, questions, comments or problems about this site please tell us. Click here to send your feedback. And if you like Argumentations.com please link to this site. It will really help a lot.
   

Tags


Related statements

View other suggested stories

Date added 
2006-04-20The Next Iraqi War? Sectarianism and Civil Conflict
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 5 -- Terrorist Safe Havens (7120 Report)
2007-11-16The Crisis Of Pakistan: A Dangerously Weak State
2007-12-27A Conversation With Benazir Bhutto
2008-06-15Trans-Saharan Migration to North Africa and the EU: Historical Roots and Current Trends
2008-10-26Afghanistan: the neo-Taliban campaign -- What Nato failed to understand
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 --
2009-05-10Country Reports on Terrorism 2008 -- Chapter 2. Country Reports: South and Central Asia Overview
2009-04-04Can Pakistan Be Governed?
2008-11-07Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2008-10-09Blaming the Victim
2008-11-11The Case for Restraint -- Foreign policy after George W. Bush
2008-11-14Towards a Grand Strategy for an Uncertain World -- Renewing Transatlantic Partnership
2008-11-24Global Trends 2025: A Transformed World -- Executive Summary
2008-12-13Getting Away with Torture?
2007-12-29Pakistan Says Bhutto’s Death Has Qaeda Link
2007-12-28Bhutto Buried as Government Orders Virtual Lockdown
2008-01-04British police start work on Bhutto probe in Pakistan
2008-01-10Can Islam change?
2008-01-11After Iraq
2008-02-23The Two Faces of Saudi Arabia
2008-05-24UN: Gross violations by Israel of housing rights in Palestine
2007-11-15Volatile Pakistan
2007-10-17Ex-premier Bhutto vows to bring democracy to Pakistan
2007-09-17Commentary: Is 'terrorist threat' to America another Bush-Cheney fabrication?
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 6 -- Terrorist Organizations
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Europe and Eurasia Overview
2007-04-17Commission Adopts Resolutions On Combating Defamation Of Religions; Right To Development
2007-06-01Islam in the West
2007-06-22Al Qaeda Strikes Back
2007-07-08Bin Laden's Fatwa
2007-07-15Hindus feel the heat in Pakistan
2007-02-26Military Commissions Act of 2006 – Turning bad policy into bad law
2007-03-01ARAB COUNTRIES - GENERAL ANALYSIS
2007-03-03Scapegoating Pakistan
2007-01-25Make War Your Friend, Part I
2007-01-06The Islamabad Dilemma - Success in Afghanistan Depends on Success in Pakistan
2007-01-14Natural Resources are Fuelling a New Cold War
2007-01-16An Honest Man Refutes Propaganda - Carter's Inconvenient Truths
2007-03-03The Synergy and Interdependence of Human Rights, Religion and Secularism
2007-03-05JOHN PILGER: THIS WAR OF LIES GOES ON
2007-03-25Shortage of women leaves surplus of disaffected men
2007-03-22Will Muslim Immigration Trigger Wars in Europe?
2007-04-12The Eurabia Code
2006-09-12The Nation That Fell to Earth
2006-05-01Nuclear, terrorism issues to dominate Bush's first South Asia trip
2006-05-01Bush: U.S. Should Welcome Competition
2006-05-01Voices Baffled, Brash and Irate in Guantánamo
2006-09-30Now Showing: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Americans - Exporting the Wrong Picture
2006-10-25US: world empire of chaos
2006-10-26Musharraf's confessions
2006-12-03The Way Out of War - A blueprint for leaving Iraq now
2007-07-12House Armed Services Committee Global Security Assessment Statement For The Record
2007-07-31CNN Late Edition with Wolf Blitzer
2007-08-06The Global Drug Meta-Group: Drugs, Managed Violence, and the Russian 9/11
2007-08-07Poll: Support for Musharraf Plummets
2007-08-07Musharraf's last gamble: A deal with Benazir?
2007-08-08Obama right on target in war on “errorism”
2007-08-08Germany Left Out of Global Policy Loop
2007-08-08Red Mosque: Endgame for Musharraf?
2007-07-07Bin Laden tape: Text
2007-07-10Female Pakistani minister shot dead for 'breaking Islamic dress code'
2007-07-01Why the Future May Not Belong to Islam
2007-06-19Comparing US & Palestine homicide rates
2007-05-30The great escape
2007-05-23Muslim Americans: Middle Class and Mostly Mainstream
2007-05-21'The Pro-Democracy Movement Must Evolve into a Major Uprising'
2007-06-02Pakistani Christian gets death for purported slur of prophet
2007-06-16The Osama Files
2007-04-15Race in Scandinavia
2007-04-15Europe's Future
2007-04-17Human Rights Council Discusses Reports On Health, Right To Food And Human Rights Defenders
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: Africa Overview
2007-05-02Country Reports on Terrorism -- Chapter 2 -- Country Reports: South and Central Asia Overview
2007-05-03Sharia Crisis in Nigeria
2007-05-05WHY IRAN WILL HAVE THE BOMB
2007-05-06Suspended Pakistani judge warns against dictatorship
2007-05-11Waning Chances for Stability -- Least Bad Options in a Failed, War-Torn State
2007-05-12Violence erupts over Pakistan's top judge, 27 dead
2007-05-15The New Demographic Balance in Europe and its Consequences
2007-09-17Why We're Losing the War on Terror
2007-09-17Musharraf to quit army post after election: lawyer
2007-09-18The Shock Doctrine: Naomi Klein on the Rise of Disaster Capitalism
2007-09-25Beneath the Hideous Veneer of "Security"
2007-09-25Distorting Desire
2007-09-25Former Prime Minister Stirs Unrest In Pakistan
2007-09-28The Mega-Lie Called the "War on Terror": A Masterpiece of Propaganda
2007-10-04Pakistan's Bhutto optimistic, no deal yet
2007-10-06Pakistan's Musharraf heads for disputed election win
2007-10-02A Tale of Extraordinary Renditions and Double-Standards -- THE FORGOTTEN PRISONER
2007-10-07Ex-spymaster set to succeed Musharraf as army chief
2007-09-07An option that doesn't really exist
2007-09-09It's the Demography, Stupid
2007-09-12Shove off Sharif -- An undeclared state of emergency
2007-09-14Bhutto to return to Pakistan on October 18
2007-09-14Islamaphobia on rise, especially in Europe - U.N. envoy
2007-09-15U.N. Expert: Defaming Religions a Threat
2007-08-08The Global War on Terrorism -- The First 100 Days
2007-08-09Pakistanis Express Ire at Army and Musharraf
2007-08-09Chaudhry chuffed
2007-08-09Political forces - Country Briefing Pakistan
2007-08-09Is Pakistan Likely to Become a Taliban State?
2007-08-09The general and the mullahs
2007-08-12Musharraf spills Muslim blood to establish America’s writ over you
2007-08-13The Limits of Multiculturalism - The Dutch Labor Party and Islam
2007-08-17Pakistan's ex-PM warns Bhutto on deal with Musharraf
2007-08-17Even Musharraf’s Allies Question His Re-election Goal
2007-08-17U.S. urges Musharraf, Bhutto to consider cooperating
2007-08-19Huge Human Cost Of Israel But Interim Peace Is Possible
2007-08-22Bhutto urges Pakistan power-share deal by end-August
2007-08-24The Challenge of Islam
2007-09-01Pakistan's Musharraf considers his options
2007-09-01Bhutto vows early Pakistan return
2007-10-19At least 130 dead as bombs target Bhutto
2007-10-19Bhutto Says She Warned of Plotting Days Before Attack
2007-10-23Pakistan Says Relations With India Are Best Since Independence
2007-11-03Musharraf clamps emergency rule on Pakistan
2007-11-04Pakistan Emergency
2007-11-04While Pakistan Burns
2007-11-04The Second Coup -- "Pakistan is on the verge of destabilization"
2007-11-04Pakistan declares state of emergency
2007-11-05Commentary: Geopolitical nightmare
2007-11-06Pakistan’s Emergency - United States in need of a Plan B
2007-11-08The Pakistan Mess -- Editorial
2007-11-08Musharraf’s Martial Plan
2007-11-08Pakistan to hold elections, lift emergency in February: official
2007-11-06UN chief and Pakistan envoy clash
2007-11-11In the Wake of War: Geo-strategy, Terrorism, Oil Markets, and Domestic Politics
2007-11-16US envoy flies in as Bhutto rejects Pakistan gov't
2007-11-11The Seven Deadly Sins of Failure in Iraq: A Retrospective Analysis of the Reconstruction
2007-11-12Bhutto says free elections in Pakistan impossible under emergency
2007-11-13The Deadly Embrace
2007-11-19Pakistan court squashes Musharraf challenges
2007-11-21Thousands freed as Pakistan eases crackdown
2007-11-21Beware Pashtunistan
2007-11-26Ex-premier Sharif joins Pakistan's election battlefield
2007-11-27Pakistan's Musharraf says goodbye to troops on eve of quitting as army chief
2007-11-27Musharraf Resigns as Pakistan’s Army Chief
2007-11-29Pakistan's Musharraf starts new term as civilian leader
2007-12-10Behind Musharraf's emergency rule
2008-05-19A Human Rights Crime In Gaza
2008-04-29Rising Euro-Muslim tensions
2008-03-29PAKISTAN & AL QAEDA: US REVIEWS OPTIONS
2008-03-29Pakistan assembly elects new PM
2008-03-31Bhutto's party delays PM candidate decision
2008-04-04Interview: Lee Kuan Yew -- Part 1
2008-04-06Benazir Bhutto's 'Reconciliation': Islam, Democracy, and the West